Annie’s Mailbox

His half-truths shake her trust

Q. “Bill’’ and I have been married for 43 years. He retired three years ago.

Last Christmas, Bill got a card with no return address. It was a card from “Betty’’ and a note telling him how much she missed him, their talks, and their lunches. She suggested they get together for a holiday lunch.

When I asked Bill why he never mentioned Betty to me, he said the lunches didn’t mean anything and he probably forgot because they were so insignificant. I don’t believe him. He put Betty’s card on display with the others, but I asked him to take it down since it wasn’t sent to us as a couple. He said he’d throw it away because it made me unhappy. The other day, I saw his old briefcase, and inside was Betty’s card. He had written her phone number on it.


If this card meant nothing to him, why keep it? Why lie to me? I love my husband. I want to trust him. I’ve never had reason not to, but I’m shaken to the core. Last week, he said he needed to run some errands and was gone for nearly two hours. He claims he ran into “Dave,’’ a former co-worker, but I wonder if this was Betty’s holiday lunch.

Get The Weekender in your inbox:
The Globe's top picks for what to see and do each weekend, in Boston and beyond.
Thank you for signing up! Sign up for more newsletters here

I hate feeling this way. My kids say to forget about it before I make myself sick. Are they right? Am I just paranoid?


A. No. Your husband is not being totally truthful about Betty, and this creates suspicion and distrust, both of which undermine your relationship. You need to talk with him and explain why his behavior is hurting you. If he cannot reassure you sufficiently, the next step is counseling.

Q. Recently, my wife and I were in Las Vegas and had a terrible experience at a buffet at one of the top hotels. I sent an e-mail to the manager, and she forwarded it to the executive chef. The executive chef apologized, invited us to dine at any of the hotel’s restaurants, and suggested the most expensive one. He met us at the restaurant and said to order anything we wanted on the menu, starting with wine. The total bill came to $350. I said we should leave a tip, but my wife (who has a restaurant background) said that when the management invites you, you do not tip. Who is right?


A. You are. The wait staff still had to work to serve you, no matter who paid the bill. Unless there was an added service charge that was then picked up by the owner, the wait staff should not be penalized because you had a bad experience at another location.


Q. “Hurt in California’’ felt bad that she called the police on a brother who might be raising children in a neglectful, possibly abusive environment.

As a person whose childhood was very similar to that scenario, I would have been rescued many times over if an adult had had the courage to call Child Protective Services. I cringe when I hear my aunts say they still wonder whether they should have done the same, but “didn’t want to interfere.’’

Please take the risk of sticking up for those kids. They will remember for the rest of their lives that someone was paying attention.


Please e-mail your questions to, or write to: Annie’s Mailbox, c/o Creators Syndicate, 737 Third St., Hermosa Beach, CA 90254.