When it comes to the latest tests of all-season and winter replacement tires, Michelin and Continental lead the way. However, tests revealed that other worthy tires were not difficult to find and many provided good overall performance.

In total, Consumer Reports tested 78 models of all season and winter tires: 20 T-speed-rated (118 miles per hour) all-season tires, 20 H-speed-rated (130 miles per hour) and 22 V-speed-rated (149 miles per hour) performance all-season tires, and 16 winter tire models.