John Dorfman column: big stocks

Do you feel better owning big, solid stocks that are among the nation’s largest companies?

Many people do. So, once a year, I offer buy and sell ratings on the 20 largest stocks, even though I prefer the opportunities in smaller stocks.

The 10 stocks I rated last year as buys achieved a 15.8 percent total return, including reinvested dividends, through Sept. 20, 2013. The four stocks on which I was neutral scored a 12 percent return. And the six I said to avoid returned 2.9 percent. Figures are total returns including dividends.


I have done nine columns in this vein since 2001. Over the nine one-year periods, my buys have averaged a 13.4 percent return, my neutrals 11 percent, and the stocks I said to avoid 8.8 percent.

Get Talking Points in your inbox:
An afternoon recap of the day’s most important business news, delivered weekdays.
Thank you for signing up! Sign up for more newsletters here

Please note that the performance of my column recommendations is theoretical, doesn’t reflect taxes or trading costs, and should never be confused with results I obtain for clients. Also, past performance doesn’t predict future results.

Here are my latest rankings, with the largest stocks first:

 Apple Inc. ($425 billion). Buy.

After the fall, Apple is a better value, selling for less than 12 times earnings. It boasts $42 billion in cash and short-term investments.


 Exxon Mobil Corp. ($390 billion). Buy. The largest US oil company sells for 11 times earnings and has debt less than 8 percent of equity. I’m nervous about the Mideast: Turmoil there would raise the price of oil.

 Berkshire Hathaway Inc. ($289 billion). Buy. This vehicle for financial genius Warren Buffett isn’t the major bargain it was a year ago. But it still looks good, especially when you factor in its stakes in other companies.

 Microsoft Corp. ($273 billon). Buy. It has a profit margin of 28 percent, which is spectacular. It sells for 13 times earnings, which is attractive. I think it will manage to make the transition to mobile devices.

 Johnson & Johnson ($253 billion). Neutral. I am getting a bit nervous about its valuations: 20 times earnings and 3.6 times book value (corporate net worth per share).

 Google Inc. ($247 billion). Avoid. It’s a great, innovative company. But the once-red-hot growth is slowing and I think that 26 times earnings is a bit too much to pay.


 Wal-Mart Stores Inc. ($247 billion). Avoid. I see nothing to get excited about here. The biggest US discounter is a mature company now.


 General Electric Co. ($245 billion). Avoid. GE makes great turbines and generators, but seems to lack an engine of growth right now.

 Chevron Corp. ($241 billion). Buy. This major energy producer looks cheap at 10 times earnings, and yields better than 3 percent in dividends.

 Wells Fargo & Co. ($227 billion). Neutral. With mortgage refinancing activity likely to be down in the next 12 months, I think the stock will just be a market performer.

 Procter & Gamble Co. ($217 billion). Avoid. People pay too much for steady earnings. I dislike the whole consumer staples sector and don’t recommend P&G at 20 times earnings.

 International Business Machines Corp. ($208 billion). Avoid. Revenue and earnings declined in the past year, and I don’t like the leveraged balance sheet.

 JP Morgan Chase Co. ($200 billion). Buy. As I predicted, the “London whale” scandal proved to be a blip. I think the same will happen with the investigation into the big bank’s activities in the electricity market. The stock sells for near book value.

 Pfizer Inc. ($192 billion). Buy. Major penetration in emerging markets is a strong point. I also like the 3.3 percent dividend yield.

 AT&T Inc. ($182 billion). Buy. There has been no growth in earnings lately, and very little growth in revenue. The 5.2 percent dividend yield is the big attraction.

 Coca-Cola Co. ($175 billion). Avoid. I consider 21 times earnings too much to pay for Coke’s moderate growth.

 Oracle Corp. ($158 billion). Avoid. The once-vaunted growth of the database leader has slowed to a walk. The stock is not cheap enough to compensate.

 Citigroup Inc. ($156 billion). Avoid. Mediocre profitability (with a return on equity last year less than 6 percent) doesn’t draw me, even though the stock seems cheap.

 Bank of America Corp. ($155 billion). Avoid. This bank has come a long way back from the financial crisis, but profitability is not yet impressive.

 Verizon Communications Inc. ($137 billion). Avoid. The balance sheet is so-so and will get worse as the company pays through the nose to acquire Vodafone’s stake in Verizon Wireless.

Disclosure: I own AT&T, Berkshire Hathaway, Exxon Mobil, Johnson & Johnson, JPMorgan Chase, Merck, Microsoft, and Pfizer for clients.

John Dorfman is chairman of Thunderstorm Capital in Boston.