Personal Finance

The latest ‘Old Faithful’ picks

I don’t call it “Old Faithful” for nothing.

Stocks that I’ve recommended in this column, drawn from the Old Faithful stock screen from 1999 to the present, have beaten the Standard & Poor’s 500 nine times over 11 one-year periods.

Here are the past year’s results, based on total returns from April 30, 2013, through April 25, 2014, in percentages:


American Railcar Industries Inc., up 89.9.

Get Talking Points in your inbox:
An afternoon recap of the day’s most important business news, delivered weekdays.
Thank you for signing up! Sign up for more newsletters here

Northrop Grumman Corp., up 57.2.

Holly Frontier Corp., up 12.3.

Employers Holdings Inc., down 10.4.

Select Comfort Corp., down 13.0.


In the aggregate, my five Old Faithful picks advanced 27.2 percent, besting the 16.6 percent return on the S&P 500.

Bear in mind that past performance doesn’t predict future results. The results of my column picks are hypothetical and don’t reflect trading costs or taxes.

How it works — Old Faithful is a fairly conventional, but demanding, stock-picking screen. For a stock to qualify it must have a market value of $250 million or more, and show strength in four different areas:

 Profitability. The return on stockholders’ equity must be 15 percent or better.

 Growth. Earnings growth the past five years must be 15 percent or better.


 Balance sheet. Debt must be less than 50 percent of stockholders’ equity.

 Valuation. The stock must sell for no more than 15 times the past four quarters’ earnings and no more than two times revenue.

Over the years, I’ve generally observed that from 20 to 50 stocks on this screen at any given time. At present, 33 pass (using software from TD Ameritrade Institutional).

Of those 33, I’ve selected five to recommend for Old Faithful’s twelfth year.

Mueller Industries — Mueller, of Memphis, is a leading supplier of plumbing, heating, ventilation, and cooling products. Items like refrigerator coils and copper tubing may not drip with glamour, but Mueller has been solidly profitable for years, has increased its dividend recently, and has shown some insider buying.

If you believe, as I do, that housing is going to pick up in the United States in the next three to five years, Mueller is a good backdoor play.

Northrop Grumman — Northrop still passes the Old Faithful screen, despite its big run-up in the past 12 months. The Falls Church, Va., company makes combat aircraft, defense electronics, drones, and other defense products.

The world keeps furnishing reminders — many of them lately from Russia and Iran – that there are limits to how far the United States can prudently cut defense spending. At 13 times earnings, I think this stock is a good bet.

Western Refining — Western Refining, of El Paso, Texas, is one of the less popular stocks in an out-of-favor group, refiners. I like the group, partly because I think the price of refiners’ raw material, oil, will stay under control for a year or two, and partly because I expect a rebound in gasoline consumption.

Western operates three refineries, an asphalt manufacturing plant, and more than 200 gas stations. Its return on stockholders’ equity exceeded 30 percent last year.

Sturm Ruger — Sturm, of Southport, Conn., makes rifles and handguns. It has been posting record sales and earnings of late, and is opening a third plant to deal with the high demand.

The periodic occurrence of mass shootings, including some of school children, has increased pressure for stricter gun control. I favor it, as do some politicians, but there is no strong consensus for it in the country, nor in Congress.

The Gap — Fashion is a fickle business. The Gap, like all clothing chains, goes in and out of fashion. But it seems to me that it spends a higher percentage of its time in sync with the consumer than most chains do, and recovers faster from its stumbles.

Of 33 analysts who follow Gap, 23 current rate it a lowly “hold.” That may not sound bad, but it’s analyst-speak for “well, she has a nice personality.” At 14 times earnings, I think Gap stock is attractive.

Will these five picks enable my Old Faithful series to continue its winning streak? I can never be sure, but I know this screen has served me well over the years.

John Dorfman is chairman of Thunderstorm Capital in Boston and a syndicated columnist. He can be reached at