Get unlimited access to Bruins cup coverage - Just 99¢

The Boston Globe

Ideas

Ideas

Where American criminal justice went wrong

Diagnosed with cancer, a Harvard law professor raced to issue a powerful final indictment

The book was written in a hurry. It had to be, because William Stuntz was dying of cancer, and the story he wanted to tell was long and complicated. It would be the Harvard Law School professor’s final major work, a sweeping indictment of the system he had been studying for 25 years. Stuntz was 49 when he found out he had stage four colon cancer. For the remaining three years of his life, he worked on the book whenever he could: in his office at Harvard; at his family’s home in Belmont; even at the Massachusetts General Hospital Cancer Center, where he would sit with his laptop in the infusion chair and type. Stuntz passed up pain medication so he could think more clearly. In the final days, after he entered hospice care, he had his assistant mail him a draft of his manuscript so he could go over any last minute changes.

Are you a home delivery subscriber?

Get FREE access as part of your print subscription

Start Here

Contact us for help

  • Phone

    888-MY-GLOBE

    Monday-Friday 6:00 a.m.- 5:00 p.m.

    Saturday, Sunday and Holidays 7:30 a.m.- 12:00 noon

  • Chat

    Start a chat

    Monday-Sunday 8:00 a.m.- 5:00 p.m.

  • E-mail

    support@bostonglobe.com

Comments

Thank you for this excellent story. I think Professor Stuntz is telling us that the justice system is a mirror of our social values, reflecting ingrained racism and deliberate economic inequity. That's why there's no six-step "how to" chapter at the end. We can "reform" procedures this way and that; but the results will always be what we want them to be, what politicians see that the voters want. We are faced now with the disgraceful truth that middle-class white America is finally interested in reducing our outrageous imprisonment rates -- but only to save money. A nation full of lives and families and communities destroyed by a manipulated legal system was not enough of a reason. And because the reason is wrong, the result will again backfire. Michelle Alexander's book, "The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness," tells the same saddening and infuriating story. But she does talk about remedy, and I encourage everyone -- everyone -- to read her book, too. It is breathtaking, it is shocking. Repairing this wrong will take a moral revolution, one that is long overdue.

Thanks for a fine portrait of an important thinker. While the race issue is a big part of the picture, the extent to which the legal system has abandoned a search for truth and justice holds for anyone. It is not news that the system has given priority to procedure over content. Perhaps this book can stimulate a process of transition.