Annie's Mailbox

Ask Amy column

Q. About 10 years ago, my father-in-law told my mother-in-law he wanted a divorce. My wife describes her parents’ marriage as a loveless union, though her father is a great dad.

My mother-in-law ended up with the house, part of his pension, etc., but her bitterness has not abated, and she has taken to accusing him of entering her home.

She works part time and is out of the house for a couple of hours a few times a day. Although her ex-husband lives about 60 miles from her, she insists that he enters the house when she is working.


She has had the locks changed on her doors at least four times (she insists he has a “master” key). She has reported specific days when she “knows” he was in her house, even though we know it was impossible because he was hundreds of miles away on those days.

Get The Weekender in your inbox:
The Globe's top picks for what to see and do each weekend, in Boston and beyond.
Thank you for signing up! Sign up for more newsletters here

She calls my wife a couple of times a week about this and is driving my wife crazy, with screaming matches taking place over the phone that inevitably end with my wife in tears. I told my wife that her mother is manipulating her, trying to get her to declare exclusive loyalty. Short of ending her relationship with her mother, I don’t know what to tell my wife to put an end to this nonsense. Any suggestions?

Had it Husband

A. You have concluded that this behavior is a deliberate manipulation. I think it’s possible that your mother-in-law may have some sort of cognitive impairment. Her paranoia and confusion should worry, rather than enrage, you.

Your wife does not need to engage with her mother about this because she knows her mother’s accusations are not accurate. The first and most important response she should give is to take her to get a thorough medical checkup.

If all medical reasons are ruled out, your wife should disengage by saying, “I don’t want to talk about this with you, Mom. Let’s talk later.”


Q. My unmarried niece is expecting a baby. My sister says it is OK to give unwed mothers a baby shower. I realize it is done all the time, but I am unable to get excited about the baby. I feel it is in bad taste to give my niece a shower. What do you think? At what point in the pregnancy should a baby shower be given?

Upset Aunt

A. You don’t need to get excited about this baby. Nor do you need to attend a baby shower. However, you should know that this baby is joining your family, regardless of your attitude.

Friends (or a different aunt) of the expectant mother should host a shower for the baby late in the pregnancy.

Q. “Heartbroken” wondered whether to invite her estranged (combative and drinking) father to her graduation party. I was in her shoes. My dad, an alcoholic, was in and out of rehab.

While I was discussing graduation details with my mother, I had her put my dad on the phone while he was (relatively) sober. I told him that I wanted him to see me graduate, but that he had to be sober the entire trip because I had no intention of worrying about him while I was celebrating a major life achievement. I told him to stay home if he didn’t think he could stay sober during the visit.


He came, he stayed sober (at least as far as I know), and everyone had a wonderful time. He eventually returned to rehab and, thank God, was sober when he died. Tell Heartbroken to be honest with her dad.

Send questions via e-mail to or by mail to Ask Amy, Chicago Tribune, TT500, 435 N. Michigan Ave., Chicago, IL 60611.