Bulger’s girlfriend considers guilty plea

This 2000 file photo showed Catherine Greig, left, and James “Whitey” Bulger, in portraits released by the FBI.
The Boston Globe/file
This 2000 file photo showed Catherine Greig, left, and James “Whitey” Bulger, in portraits released by the FBI.

James “Whitey Bulger’s girlfriend, Catherine Greig, is considering pleading guilty to helping the gangster evade capture for more than 16 years, according to several relatives of Bulger’s alleged victims.

Steven Davis, whose sister Debra was one of 19 people allegedly murdered by Bulger, said a victims’ advocate for the US Attorney’s office told him Friday that Greig’s lawyers have indicated she wants to plead guilty to the single charge of conspiracy to harbor a fugitive.

“There is no plea bargain,” said Davis, adding that he has been told Greig has not been given a deal by prosecutors and faces up to five years in prison on the harboring charge.


It is unclear whether Greig could be forced to testify against Bulger, 82, a longtime FBI informant who is scheduled to stand trial in November in a sweeping federal racketeering case. That case alleges the South Boston crime boss killed 19 people in the 1970s and 1980s.

Get Fast Forward in your inbox:
Forget yesterday's news. Get what you need today in this early-morning email.
Thank you for signing up! Sign up for more newsletters here

A spokeswoman for the US Attorney’s office declined to comment on the potential plea and Greig’s lawyer, Kevin J. Reddington of Brockton, could not be reached. Greig, 60, is scheduled to stand trial May 7 and is expected to appear Wednesday in US District Court in Boston for a hearing on her case.

“If that’s what she wants to do is plead guilty, what else can you do but accept that?” said Davis, adding that he would not be disappointed if there was no trial in Greig’s case because she is not charged with any of the murders and has no prior record. “Get rid of her [case] and we can all focus on him, Whitey.”

Patricia Donahue, whose husband Michael was shot and killed allegedly by Bulger in 1982 on the South Boston waterfront, said Friday that she was disappointed by the prospect that Greig would resolve her case without being compelled to testify against Bulger.

“I’m not happy,” Donahue said.


Greig’s sister, Margaret McCusker, answered the door at her South Boston apartment Friday night, but would not speak with a reporter.

Prosecutors have asked relatives of Bulger’s alleged victims to meet with them Monday to talk about the proposed plea and any objections they may have, said Davis, whose 26-year-old sister Debra was allegedly strangled by Bulger in 1981.

Bulger, who fled just before his January 1995 federal racketeering indictment after being warned by his former FBI handler that he was about to be arrested, was a fixture on the FBI’s Ten Most Wanted list. He was finally captured on June 22 in Santa Monica, Calif., with Greig, a former dental hygienist who lived in South Boston and Quincy.

The FBI found more than $800,000 cash and 30 weapons hidden inside the walls of the rent-controlled apartment where the couple had lived as Charles and Carol Gasko for at least 13 years, according to the FBI. They also found numerous false identities allegedly used by the couple.

In court last November, prosecutors said they planned to bring additional charges against Greig within a few weeks, possibly involving the weapons and fake identities. But, to date, no new charges been brought against her.


“I would like to see her charged with the guns and the money they found in California,” Patricia Donahue said. “I don’t really care about her [Greig], but I’m not happy with the way the government is handling this.”

Donahue’s son, Shawn, said his family was hoping prosecutors could explain to them the status of the potential charges against Greig stemming from the discovery of the guns and cash in the apartment.

Prosecutors allege that Greig joined Bulger on the run in early 1995 and helped him evade capture by running errands for him, picking up his prescriptions, and paying their utility bills.

“If she’s just pleading out to the harboring charge, she’ll be getting off easy,” Shawn Donahue said.

He said his family also wants to know if Greig can be compelled to testify against Bulger.

Since they were returned to Boston last year, Greig has remained jailed without bail at a Rhode Island facility and Bulger is being held at the Plymouth County Correctional Facility.

Bill St. Croix, whose 26-year-old sister was allegedly strangled in 1985 by Bulger and St. Croix’s father, Stephen “The Rifleman” Flemmi, said Greig has the right to plead guilty and he does not hold her responsible for his sister’s death.

“I have no animosity toward her,” said St. Croix. “Her going to jail is not going to benefit anybody. I get no just desserts seeing this woman suffer.”

Greig’s attorney, Reddington, has argued in court that her only crime was falling in love with Bulger and she had no knowledge of any of his crimes. He also said she would not cooperate against Bulger.

St. Croix said he believed Greig would only cooperate against Bulger if he advised her to do so to win some leniency.

“I imagine she’s old school ... and is going to keep her mouth shut and take one for the team,” St. Croix said. “I don’t think she would cooperate against Jimmy unless Jimmy and her had discussed this prior.”

Globe Correspondent Dan Adams contributed to this report.