Next Score View the next score

    Some insist Obama can do a lot alone on immigration

    Leading legal analysts say the Obama administration has wide latitude to take certain actions when it comes to immigration policies.
    Associated Press/File
    Leading legal analysts say the Obama administration has wide latitude to take certain actions when it comes to immigration policies.

    WASHINGTON — A consensus is emerging among legal scholars that President Obama can do a lot without Congress to change US immigration policies.

    There are some limits under federal law, and anything the White House decides to do may be challenged in court as unconstitutional.

    But leading legal analysts say the administration has wide legal latitude to delay indefinitely efforts to deport millions of immigrants already in the United States illegally, and it could give them official work permits that would allow them to legally find jobs, obtain driver’s licenses, and pay income taxes.


    Without approval from Congress, they say, Obama could not generally give large groups of immigrants permission to remain permanently in the United States, and he could not grant them American citizenship.

    Get Ground Game in your inbox:
    Daily updates and analysis on national politics from James Pindell.
    Thank you for signing up! Sign up for more newsletters here

    He also could not generally make them eligible for federal or state social benefit programs, such as welfare payments, food stamps, or the administration’s health care plans.

    ‘‘There is prosecutorial discretion which can be exercised in these sorts of situations,’’ said Leon Rodriguez, a former Justice Department lawyer and the newly confirmed director for US Citizenship and Immigration Services. ‘‘In most enforcement realms, generally there is pretty broad discretion.’’ Rodriguez spoke last week during an oversight hearing for the House Judiciary Committee.

    With Congress declining to approve significant changes to immigration laws, the White House is hinting that Obama is considering broadening a program known as Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals to temporarily shield from deportation many young immigrants who came to the United States as children and allow them to get a work permit.

    Immigration reform advocates have been pushing to include parents of US citizens and the parents of young immigrants already protected under the earlier program, which covers more than 700,000 immigrants so far.


    All told, expanding the program could affect as many as 5 million immigrants who came to the United States illegally.

    Republicans in Congress, including House Speaker John Boehner, have complained that Obama is failing to enforce US laws by effectively disregarding illegal immigration. The House Judiciary Committee chairman, Representative Bob Goodlatte, Republican of Virginia, said Obama’s immigration policies are ‘‘undermining the fundamental constitutional principles that Congress creates the law and president is bound to enforce them.’’

    In a direct challenge to Obama’s policies, the Republican-led House on Friday night passed legislation that appeared designed to prevent those who have already gotten work permits under the deferred action program from renewing them, ultimately making them subject to deportation. With the Senate controlled by Democrats, the bill seemed unlikely to advance.

    So, how powerfully can Obama act without approval by Congress?

    Obama announced in March that he had directed Homeland Security Secretary Jeh Johnson to review the administration’s immigration enforcement polices and recommend any possible changes. In May, Obama delayed the review to give Congress time to act on im-migration reform before it adjourned this week for the summer.


    Before leaving for the August recess Congress did not pass emergency legislation to provide the funding Obama requested to help deal with the more than 57,000 unaccompanied child immigrants, mostly from Central America, who have crossed the border since Oct. 1.

    Obama said Friday that House Republicans were trying to pass the ‘‘most extreme and unworkable bills,’’ knowing they wouldn’t make it to his desk. On Friday night, the House approved a bill that would send migrant youths back home without hearings, a measure that also appeared destined to go nowhere in the Senate.

    ‘‘That means while they’re out on vacation, I’m going to have to make some tough choices to meet the challenge, with or without Congress,’’ the president said.

    Immigration law requires congressional action to create a benefit program for a specific class of people. The Obama administration said the young immigrants protected under the childhood arrivals program don’t count as a class because each request not to be deported is reviewed individually, on a case-by-case basis.

    David Leopold, a Cleveland immigration lawyer who has supported Obama’s previous administrative changes to immigration law, said nothing in the law requires the government to deport every immigrant living in the country illegally. The law ‘‘makes someone deportable, but that boils down to enforcement of immigration law. And that is open to enforcement priorities,’’ he said.