Russian hackers exploit weakness in US cyber defense

WASHINGTON — Russian hackers exploited a key vulnerability in US cyber defenses to come within reach of stealing some of the nation’s most secret and advanced defense technology, an Associated Press investigation has found.

What may have been stolen is uncertain, but the cyberspies clearly took advantage of poorly protected e-mail and scant direct notification of victims.

The hackers known as Fancy Bear, who also intruded in the US election, went after at least 87 people working on military drones, missiles, rockets, stealth fighter jets, cloud-computing platforms, or other sensitive activities, the AP found. Thirty-one agreed to interviews.


Employees at both small companies and defense giants such as Lockheed Martin Corp., Raytheon Co., Boeing Co., Airbus Group, and General Atomics were targeted. Contacted by the AP, those companies offered no comment.

Get Ground Game in your inbox:
Daily updates and analysis on national politics from James Pindell.
Thank you for signing up! Sign up for more newsletters here

‘‘The programs that they appear to target and the people who work on those programs are some of the most forward-leaning, advanced technologies,’’ said Charles Sowell, a former senior adviser in the Office of the US Director of National Intelligence, who reviewed the list of names for the AP. ‘‘And if those programs are compromised in any way, then our competitive advantage and our defense is compromised.’’

‘‘That’s what’s really scary,’’ added Sowell, who was himself one of the hacking targets.

The AP identified Fancy Bear’s prey from about 19,000 lines of the hackers’ e-mail phishing data collected by the US-based cybersecurity company Secureworks, which calls the hackers Iron Twilight. The data is partial and extends from March 2015 to May 2016.

Most of the people on the target list worked on classified projects. Yet as many as 40 percent clicked on the hackers’ phishing links, the AP analysis indicates. That’s the first step in potentially opening their accounts or computer files to digital theft.


Hackers predominantly targeted personal Gmail, with a few corporate accounts mixed in. Personal accounts can convey classified information — whether through carelessness or expediency — and lead to more valuable targets or carry embarrassing personal details that can be used for blackmail or to recruit spies.

Among their interests, the Russians seemed to be eyeing the X-37B, an American unmanned space plane that looks like a miniature shuttle.

Referring to an X-37B flight in May 2015, Russian Deputy Prime Minister Dmitry Rogozin invoked it as evidence that his country’s space program was faltering. ‘‘The United States is pushing ahead,’’ he warned Russian lawmakers.

Less than two weeks later, Fancy Bear tried to penetrate the Gmail account of a senior engineer on the X-37B project at Boeing.

The hackers also chased people who work on cloud-based services, the off-site computer networks that enable collaborators to work with data that is sometimes classified. For example, the cyberspies tried to get into the Gmail of an employee at Mellanox Federal Systems, which helps the government with high-speed storage networks, data analysis, and cloud computing. Its clients include the FBI and other intelligence agencies.


Yet of the 31 targets reached by AP, just one got any warning from US officials.

The FBI declined to give on-the-record details of its response to this Russian operation. Agency spokeswoman Jillian Stickels said the FBI does sometimes notify individual targets. ‘‘The FBI takes . . . all potential threats to public and private sector systems very seriously,’’ she said in an e-mail.

However, three people familiar with the matter — including a current and a former government official — previously told the AP that the FBI knew the details of Fancy Bear’s phishing campaign for more than a year.

Pressed about notification in that case, a senior FBI official, who was not authorized to publicly discuss the hacking operation because of its sensitivity, said the bureau was overwhelmed by the sheer number of attempted hacks. ‘‘It’s a matter of triaging to the best of our ability the volume of the targets who are out there,’’ he said.