Israeli denies any promise to rule out attack on Iran

Words show rift with US over diplomacy paths

JERUSALEM - Defense Minister Ehud Barak of Israel said Tuesday his country has never promised the United States it would hold off from attacking Iran while nuclear talks were taking place.

The comments, in which Barak said a diplomatic push to reach a compromise with Iran was a waste of “precious time,’’ further exposed a rift between Israel and the United States over how to deal with Iran and its nuclear program.

“We are not committing to anything,’’ Barak told Israel’s Army Radio. “The dialogue with the Americans is both direct and open.’’


Israel, arguing that a nuclear Iran would pose an existential threat, has said it will not allow Tehran to acquire a nuclear weapon. It cites Iranian calls for Israel’s destruction, Iran’s support for Arab militant groups, and its development of missiles capable of striking the Jewish state.

Get Today's Headlines in your inbox:
The day's top stories delivered every morning.
Thank you for signing up! Sign up for more newsletters here

Fearing that Iran is moving quickly toward nuclear capability, Israel has repeatedly hinted at an attack if Iran’s uranium enrichment program continues to advance.

Enrichment is a key process in developing weapons, and Israel says Iran is closely approaching a point where it can no longer be stopped.

Meanwhile, Iran’s armed forces will make its enemies regret any act of aggression against the Islamic Republic, President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad warned on Tuesday as Iranians marked National Army Day with a military parade near Tehran.

Although Ahmadinejad did not specify any countries, such language used by Iranian officials is a common reference to the West, especially the United States and Israel.


The harsh tone was typical of speeches for military events, but it contrasted sharply with a sense of cautious progress after the direct talks with world powers last week on Tehran’s nuclear ambitions.

The United States favors diplomacy and economic sanctions and has said military action on Iran’s nuclear facilities should be only a last resort if all else fails.

Officials from the United States, Russia, China, Britain, France, and Germany met with Iran in Istanbul last weekend to discuss the country’s nuclear program.

The talks were described as positive, and the parties agreed to meet again on May 23 in Baghdad.

Barak told Israel’s Army Radio he did not believe the talks would prevent Iran from developing a nuclear weapon. “We regret the time being lost. This is precious time,’’ he said.


Barak said the talks needed to yield quick results.

“It requires a few direct meetings where all the demands are put on the table. There you can see if the other side is playing for time, drawing it out through the year, or if indeed the other side is genuinely striving to find a solution,’’ he said. “In this light, any ‘time-outs,’ especially when they are this long, do not serve our interests,’’ he said.

“Unfortunately, we maintain the view that this will probably not have an impact or bring the Iranians to cease their nuclear program. Of course we will be happy to be proven wrong,’’ he added.

Earlier this week, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel said Iran got a “freebie’’ from the international community, saying the May meeting gave the Iranians an additional five weeks to continue uranium enrichment without any restrictions. He said Iran should be forced to stop this immediately.

Netanyahu was publicly rebuked by President Obama, who said the United States had not “given anything away’’ in the talks.

Iran insists its nuclear program is for peaceful purposes and says it does not seek a bomb.