CERN scientists have strong evidence ‘God particle’ exists

An illustration showed what the long-presumed Higgs boson particle is thought to look like.

Anja Niedringhaus/AP File

An illustration showed what the long-presumed Higgs boson particle is thought to look like.

GENEVA (AP) — Scientists working at the world’s biggest atom smasher plan to announce Wednesday that they have gathered enough evidence to show that the long-sought ‘‘God particle’’ answering fundamental questions about the universe almost certainly does exist.

Anja Niedringhaus/AP File

A wall painting by artist Josef Kristofoletti at the Atlas experiment site at outside Geneva. The painting shows how a Higgs boson may look.

But after decades of work and billions of dollars spent, researchers at the European Organization for Nuclear Research, or CERN, aren’t quite ready to say they've ‘‘discovered’’ the particle.


Instead, experts familiar with the research at CERN’s vast complex on the Swiss-French border say that the massive data they have obtained will essentially show the footprint of the key particle known as the Higgs boson — all but proving it exists — but doesn’t allow them to say it has actually been glimpsed.

It appears to be a fine distinction.

Get Today's Headlines in your inbox:
The day's top stories delivered every morning.
Thank you for signing up! Sign up for more newsletters here

Senior CERN scientists say that the two independent teams of physicists who plan to present their work at CERN’s vast complex on the Swiss-French border on July 4 are about as close as you can get to a discovery without actually calling it one.

‘‘I agree that any reasonable outside observer would say, ‘It looks like a discovery,'’’ British theoretical physicist John Ellis, a professor at King’s College London who has worked at CERN since the 1970s, told The Associated Press. ‘‘We've discovered something which is consistent with being a Higgs.’’

Meenakshi Narain, a physics professor at Brown University who works on one of the Higgs boson experiments, said that although she could not disclose what would be announced on Wednesday, this was a “once in a lifetime event,” because the experiments now provided enough data to give “at least the first hints of it in a significant way,” or to rule the Higgs out.  She and her students and her children will be in the laboratory July 4 at 3 a.m., watching the announcement, streaming on the web.


If the Higgs is discovered, “this would be really something very, very, very exciting,” Narain said. “And if we were to not find it, rule it out even in this mass range, it would be even more exciting because we’d have to go back to the chalkboard and figure out what was going on.”

Markus Klute, an MIT physicist also involved in the Higgs hunt, said anticipation is high and he has barely slept in four weeks. Klute said in a telephone interview from Geneva that he will depart Tuesday for Melbourne, Australia, where he will present the results from one of the analyses that underlies the new finding to an international particle physics conference.

“There is nothing routine in this,” Klute said. “It’s incredibly exciting to look at this data. You have to understand, the community is looking for evidence for this new particle for the last 40 years. This will tell us about the presence or not of this particle.”

CERN’s atom smasher, the $10 billion Large Hadron Collider, has been creating high-energy collisions of protons to help them understand suspected phenomena such as dark matter, antimatter and ultimately the creation of the universe billions of years ago, which many theorize occurred as a massive explosion known as the Big Bang.

For particle physicists, finding the Higgs boson is a key to confirming the standard model of physics that explains what gives mass to matter and, by extension, how the universe was formed. Each of the two teams known as ATLAS and CMS involve thousands of people working independently from one another, to ensure accuracy.

Rob Roser, who leads the search for the Higgs boson at the Fermilab in Chicago, said: ‘‘Particle physicists have a very high standard for what it takes to be a discovery,’’ and he thinks it is a hair’s breadth away.

Rosen compared the results that scientists are preparing to announce Wednesday to finding the fossilized imprint of a dinosaur: ‘‘You see the footprints and the shadow of the object, but you don’t actually see it.’’

Though an impenetrable concept to many, the Higgs boson has until now been just that — a concept intended to explain a riddle: How were the subatomic particles, such as electrons, protons and neutrons, themselves formed? What gives them their mass?

The answer came in a theory first proposed by physicist Peter Higgs and others in the 1960s. It envisioned an energy field where particles interact with a key particle, the Higgs boson.

The idea is that other particles attract Higgs bosons and the more they attract, the bigger their mass will be. Some liken the effect to a ubiquitous Higgs snowfield that affects other particles traveling through it depending on whether they are wearing, metaphorically speaking, skis, snowshoes or just shoes.

Officially, CERN is presenting its evidence at a physics conference in Australia this week, but plans to accompany the announcement with meetings in Geneva. The two teams, ATLAS and CMS, then plan to publicly unveil more data on the Higgs boson at physics meetings in October and December.

Scientists with access to the new CERN data say it shows with a high degree of certainty that the Higgs boson may already have been glimpsed, and that by unofficially combining the separate results from ATLAS and CMS it can be argued that a discovery is near at hand. Ellis says at least one physicist-blogger has done just that in a credible way.

CERN spokesman James Gillies said Monday, however, that he would be ‘‘very cautious’’ about unofficial combinations of ATLAS and CMS data. ‘‘Combining the data from two experiments is a complex task, which is why it takes time, and why no combination will be presented on Wednesday,’’ he told AP.

But if the calculations are indeed correct, said John Guinon, a longtime physics professor at the University of California at Davis and author of the book ‘‘The Higgs Hunter’s Guide,’’ then it is fair to say that ‘‘in some sense we have reached the mountaintop.’’

Frank Wilczek, a Nobel laureate and physics professor at MIT, said that he plans to either stay up late or get up early to watch the scientific presentation. He said that while he had no inside information, it seemed likely that even if the teams did not announce the actual discovery of the particle, they had come very close to it.

“It’s a very sort of historic moment for physics, because we had this standard model working extremely well and going from triumph to triumph and this is kind of the last important piece,” Wilczek said. He also said he hoped that the discovery would finally convince his colleague at MIT, Janet Conrad, to concede that he had won a bet they made in 2005. Wilczek predicted the Large Hadron Collider would measure the Higgs, and that the particle would be below a certain mass.

“I’m winning the bet; I’ve been urging Janet to pay up,” Wilczek said. “She said it’s not quite decisive yet.”

He said he hoped that after this press conference, she would give him his prize – 10 chocolate wafers the same size as the Nobel Prize, wrapped in gold foil.

Carolyn Johnson of The Boston Globe contributed to this report.
Loading comments...
Real journalists. Real journalism. Subscribe to The Boston Globe today.
You're reading  1 of 5 free articles.
Get UNLIMITED access for only 99¢ per week Subscribe Now >
You're reading1 of 5 free articles.Keep scrolling to see more articles recomended for you Subscribe now
We hope you've enjoyed your 5 free articles.
Continue reading by subscribing to for just 99¢.
 Already a member? Log in Home
Subscriber Log In

We hope you've enjoyed your 5 free articles'

Stay informed with unlimited access to Boston’s trusted news source.

  • High-quality journalism from the region’s largest newsroom
  • Convenient access across all of your devices
  • Today’s Headlines daily newsletter
  • Subscriber-only access to exclusive offers, events, contests, eBooks, and more
  • Less than 25¢ a week
Marketing image of
Marketing image of