Syria accused of using cluster bombs on opposition

Human rights group cites video and testimony

Image from video taken by a citizen and provided by Ugarit News shows what Human Rights Watch says are cluster bombs.
Human Rights Watch
Image from video taken by a citizen and provided by Ugarit News shows what Human Rights Watch says are cluster bombs.

BEIRUT — The Syrian regime was accused Sunday of dropping cluster bombs — indiscriminate scattershot munitions banned by most nations — in a new sign of desperation and disregard for its own people.

The international group ­Human Rights Watch cited amateur video and testimony from the front lines in making the allegation against the government of President Bashar ­Assad.

Syria and Turkey, meanwhile, declared their skies off-limits to each other amid mounting cross-border tensions in Syria’s 19-month-old conflict. Turkey is an outspoken backer of rebels trying to oust Assad.


The weekend’s mutual ban on overflights is part of Turkey’s increasingly assertive stance toward Syria that has stirred concerns about a regional conflagration. In the past two weeks, Turkey has retaliated for stray Syrian shells and mortar rounds, intercepted a Syrian passenger plane on suspicion it carried military equipment, and — according to a Turkish newspaper Sunday — sent more warships to naval bases north of the Syrian coastline.

Get Today's Headlines in your inbox:
The day's top stories delivered every morning.
Thank you for signing up! Sign up for more newsletters here

Inside Syria, rebel fighters and regime forces have been locked in a bloody stalemate for weeks, with rebels holding large rural stretches in the heavily populated western area, but unable to dislodge Assad’s troops from urban centers. During the summer, the regime escalated shelling and air strikes on rebel-held neighborhoods.

Human Rights Watch said new amateur videos and interviews with residents suggests the Syrian air force has dropped cluster bombs in the past week, mainly along a main north-south highway in western Syria that runs through Maaret al-Numan, a town captured by rebels after fierce fighting.

Cluster bombs open in flight, scattering smaller bomblets over a wide area. Many of the bomblets don’t explode immediately, posing a threat to civilians long afterward.

Steve Goose, an arms expert for the New York-based human rights group, said most nations have already banned cluster bombs and that many of those that have not, including the United States, said they would do so soon.


‘‘These are weapons that are really beyond the pale,’’ Goose said in a phone interview. ‘‘This is a weapon of desperation [for Syria] at this point in time.’’

The Syrian government had no immediate comment.

First word of cluster bombs being dropped by the regime emerged in July, but the recent reports indicated a more widespread use, said Nadim Houry, a Lebanon-based researcher for Human Rights Watch.

Sunday’s report said activists posted at least 18 videos in the past week showing remnants of the bombs in or near the central city of Homs, the northern cities of Idlib and Aleppo, rural areas near the town of Latakia, and the eastern Ghouta district close to the capital of Damascus. The group ­also spoke to residents in the towns of Taftanaz and Tamane who said cluster bombs were dropped there on Tuesday.

There was no immediate report of casualties from the recent cluster bombs, the report said, adding that the munitions shown in the videos were made in the Soviet Union, which before its collapse in 1991 was a major arms supplier to Syria.


The death toll in Syria’s conflict crossed the threshold of 33,000, according to the Syrian Observatory for Human Rights, a Britain-based organization that gathers reports from a network of activists.

The group said it counted 33,204 dead as of Friday, including 23,752 civilians or civilians-turned-rebel gunmen, 1,241 army defectors fighting with the rebels, and 8,211 regime soldiers.

The rebels’ foreign backers, including Turkey, have shied away from direct military intervention, fearing to get dragged into a quagmire without an exit strategy.

Abdelbaset Sieda, who heads the Syrian National Council, told reporters in Istanbul that the international community must establish safe havens in Syria and enforce no-fly zones to help the rebels counter the regime’s air strikes.

This would also cut down on the number of Syrians seeking refuge abroad and ‘‘resolve the humanitarian crisis, especially with winter approaching,’’ Sieda said.

International aid officials estimate the number of refugees could double by the end of the year, to more than 700,000.

Turkey has taken a notably harsher stance toward Syria since the start of the month and warned of retaliation if Syrian artillery hits Turkish soil again.

The daily newspaper Hurriyet said in an unattributed report that Turkey has reinforced four naval bases along its Mediterranean coast north of Syria.

The newspaper said Turkey sent frigates with cannons, as well as antiship and antiaircraft missiles.

Foreign Minister Ahmet Ahmet Davutoglu said Sunday that Turkey is barring Syrian ­civilian flights from Turkey’s airspace, a day after Syria ­issued a similar ban for Turkish commercial aircraft.