To continue getting breaking news and the full stories from The Boston Globe, subscribe today.

The Boston Globe

Opinion

Opinion | carlo rotella

Phone alone

Does a cellphone create too much of the wrong kind of privacy for teens?

In the morning, on my way home after walking my kids to school, I pass teenagers streaming down Tappan Street toward Brookline High. Among them is a girl who’s always looking at her phone. She’s tall and graceful, I think, although it’s hard to tell because whenever I see her she’s bent deeply forward over the tiny screen held in front of her, a pentitential posture that has become a commonplace sight. The other day she walked right out into the street without looking up. I resist the urge to meddle, but some part of me feels that it’s my duty as an adult to advise her to put away her toy and pay attention to the world.

Tech skeptic — OK, tech crab — though I may be, I recognize that a cell phone now counts as basic equipment for living for many people, including me. And as a father whose kids will soon be teenagers and will eventually own cell phones, I accept that it can be a useful tool, especially for those of us who give our children plenty of freedom to roam the neighborhood and the city. The cell phone is wildly overrated as an emergency safety device — that teenage girl’s phone is more likely to get her run over than it is to save her from some dastardly wrongdoer — but I accept its more mundane utility. There’s a substantial body of reliable research that shows that kids whose parents know where they are and what they’re doing tend to do better in life.

Comments

actually mr. rotella, what cell phones, video games et al does in stunt the growth of that quaint little habit of being able to talk to people on a face to face basis. i believe it use to be called COMMUNICATING. ma

Sometimes the individual tuning-out-via- technology leads to collective communication as seen in flash mobs, cash mobs, political demonstrations, et al. One can imagine the next example spiking our voting style, trumping any attempts to suppress the vote of the tech savvy. "Hey, there's a short line in Ward Y, District X, let's get moving!" (Thumbs up to Sloan's illustration)