Read as much as you want on BostonGlobe.com, anywhere and anytime, for just 99¢.

JAMES CARROLL

Religious extremism: The answer is more religion

Iraqi Shiite tribal fighters deploy with their weapons to fight militants from the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant, a group that has taken over large swaths of Iraq.

AP Photo/ Karim Kadim, File

Iraqi Shiite tribal fighters deploy with their weapons to fight militants from the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant, a group that has taken over large swaths of Iraq.

One of the Sunni extremist groups wreaking such havoc in Iraq, alongside the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria, is called the 1920 Revolution Brigades. On its seal, the motto “God shall torture them by your hands” arcs across an AK-47. Rabid invoking of the Holy One in the thick of slaughter is a mark, once again, of astounding new levels of sectarian violence in Iraq. Last week hundreds of Shiite men were coldly massacred by Sunnis near Tikrit, and dozens of Sunni prisoners, in turn, were executed in a Baqouba police station north of Baghdad. The devils are loose: gunshots to the head of helpless captives, mass decapitation, even crucifixion (“Another day,” read one headline, “another ISIS crucifixion”).

When the 21st century dawned with a savage outbreak of religiously justified violence — those Al Qaeda hijacker-pilots driving jetliners into skyscrapers while crying “God is great” — many people were perplexed that such deeds were justified by appeals to the divine. The ferocity of criminal acts reflected the belief that bloodletting was required not because of an earthly power struggle, but by the will of heaven. “God” not only justified the killing, but redoubled its brutality.

Continue reading below

In the nations of the North Atlantic, believers and non-believers alike were appalled by this. Many insisted at first that “true religion” could have no truck with sacred violence. But the 21st-century explosion of an expressly Islamic holy war prompted a closer reading of Western history, forcing Europeans to reckon with the barbarity of their continent’s own post-Reformation religious wars, and Americans to think twice about George W. Bush’s callow call for a “crusade.”

But the killer God is back, and not just in Iraq. In Kenya last week, Somali gunmen from the Al Qaeda-derived Al Shabaab terrorized townspeople by knocking on doors and demanding to know the religion of those answering. “My husband told them we were were Christian,” one woman said, “and they shot him in the head.” Dozens were killed in this way. The United Nations reports a dramatic recent escalation in “high levels” of overtly religious violence, afflicting fully half of the nations of the Middle East and North Africa. Lest one assume only Arabs and Muslims are culprits, in Myanmar and Sri Lanka Muslim and Christian minorities are attacked by nationalist Buddhist terror groups, including Bodu Bala Sena, a name which means Buddhist Power Force.

This troubling resurgence of violence in the name of God must once again confront the conscience of every believer. How can this be? It is not enough to focus on today’s acts of “jihad,” as if the Koran were uniquely brutish. Indeed, given the global sweep of Islam, the impulse to avoid such blanket condemnation of Muslims is more important than ever. Nor should religion itself be tarred with the brush wielded by extremists, since faith-based entities accomplish massive works of mercy and justice across the world.

What the holy warriors miss is how every religion includes — within its dogma and tradition — the principles of its own self-criticism. The universal prohibition of idolatry, for example, means that anyone who kills wantonly, no matter the justification, is claiming an absolute moral power that does not belong to human beings. The worship of God carries with it the prohibition against the worship of the self as God. Religion so emphatically insists on this precisely because something in the human heart wants to be God, and when that something prevails, all hell breaks loose. The ultimate sin always comes disguised as salvation — a self-deception against which religion rails.

In this sense, what is needed even in an age marked by religious violence is not less religion, but more. Religion is its own antidote.

What is needed even in an age marked by religious violence is not less religion, but more. Religion is its own antidote.

Quote Icon

The secular mind, having left belief behind, can foolishly imagine itself to be above all such primitive nonsense, wanting nothing to do with the deity, much less killing for it. But the terror group that calls itself the 1920 Revolution Brigades is a reminder that the scourge of violent Islam was itself sparked by that most secular of events, World War I, which destroyed the Ottoman caliphate, and first set loose the modern jihadists who claim their acts of torture originate with God. No, they originate with humans, which is why humility is due of all of us.

James Carroll writes regularly for the Globe.
Loading comments...

You have reached the limit of 5 free articles in a month

Stay informed with unlimited access to Boston’s trusted news source.

  • High-quality journalism from the region’s largest newsroom
  • Convenient access across all of your devices
  • Today’s Headlines daily newsletter
  • Subscriber-only access to exclusive offers, events, contests, eBooks, and more
  • Less than 25¢ a week