Editorials

editorial

Ceiling fans: Big government, or just hot air?

istockphoto

While making homes more energy-efficient is a legitimate, even vital goal of federal policy, government agents aren’t about to pry inefficient fans from the ceilings of American homes. That didn’t stop Representative Marsha Blackburn, a Tennessee Republican, from pushing a measure to block any new federal energy efficiency standards for ceiling fans — or from defending that measure in overheated terms. “We’ve already seen the federal government stretch their regulatory tentacles into our homes and determine what kind of light bulbs we have to use,” Blackburn said on the House floor. “Now they’re coming after our ceiling fans. It is a sad state of affairs when even our ceiling fans aren’t safe from this administration.”

Actually, it was President Bush and a Republican Congress who called for national efficiency standards in 2005 as a way of preempting state regulations; the Department of Energy began taking steps to implement national rules this year. As well it should have: Home appliances represent a huge opportunity to reduce energy consumption, and many ceiling fans use technology that is decades old.

And for all Blackburn’s zealfor liberty, it’s also noteworthy that one of the nation’s top ceiling fan companies, Hunter Fan, is in her home state. Roll Call reported that the company has already complained about the potential costs of new rules to the Energy Department and asked for a delay “until there are further advances in fan technology.”

Advertisement

In fact, major advances are already being made by upstarts such as the brashly named Big Ass Fans, which this year earned the government’s highest Energy Star efficiency rating for models which reportedly use a third the energy of traditional ceiling fans. But if anything, companies are likely to invest more in energy-efficiency research with federal rules as a motivator. In the meantime, no one is “coming after” any homeowner’s ceiling fans, and Blackburn’s suggestion otherwise is just hot air.