Route 1 should preserve Hilltop cactus sign

The cactus sign of the now-closed Hilltop Steakhouse is part of Route 1 kitsch.
John Tlumacki/globe staff
The cactus sign of the now-closed Hilltop Steakhouse is part of Route 1 kitsch.

In the real American West, a saguaro cactus can live for as long as 200 years; on Route 1, the Hilltop Steakhouse, famed for its 66-foot cactus sign, lasted only 52, before closing last October. The cactus sign, like the mini-golf dinosaur, replica of the leaning tower of Pisa, and restaurant shaped like a sailing ship of yore, is part of a collection of Route 1 kitsch that defines a certain mid-20th century lifestyle. It recalls the days when the car was king and weekend glamour was a night in a big, colorful restaurant famed for its large portions. The suburban aesthetic may be on the outs in the era of smart growth and sustainability, but it’s also a part of history that deserves commemoration in some way.

The town of Saugus, aided by a grant from the Metropolitan Area Planning Council, is now revising its zoning, and is considering whether to allow mixed-use commercial and residential construction along Route 1. Indeed, the zoning code should be updated to encourage new development. Still, the unique look and feel of Route 1 is the kind of asset that takes decades to grow, and uprooting it altogether would be a mistake. It’s noteworthy that, in Boston, developer Steve Samuels — who is transforming the Fenway by replacing parking lots and low-slung buildings with sleek mixed-use towers — decided to fix up a down-at-heel motel rather than raze it. Similarly, giant steakhouses with acres of asphalt parking may be a thing of the past, but 66-foot cactus signs, and certain other landmarks of an earlier era, should last forever.


Thieves steal fiberglass cows from Hilltop Steak House


Vintage Hilltop souvenirs lined up for auction block

Get Arguable in your inbox:
Jeff Jacoby on everything from politics to pet peeves to the passions of the day.
Thank you for signing up! Sign up for more newsletters here

Hilltop Steakhouse, Saugus landmark, to close