Valentine not wrong to shake up Red Sox

The Red Sox have started the Bobby Valentine era with a 4-6 record.
Michael Dwyer/AP
The Red Sox have started the Bobby Valentine era with a 4-6 record.

On April 1, there was a story about Bobby Valentine in the Red Sox season preview section. And one of his former players, Al Leiter, offered what now seem like prescient words about the Red Sox manager.

Said Leiter, “Is he going to get on your nerves? Absolutely he will. If you’re sensitive, you’ll have some issues. But I had some of the best years of my career when I played for him and it was because I was prepared to pitch. He made sure of that.

“My advice to the Red Sox players is to listen to what he tells you and don’t worry about what he says to the media. If you listen to him, you’ll be a better player.”


Leiter’s words seems even more telling now given Valentine’s curiously timed comments questioning Kevin Youkilis earlier this week

Get Breaking Sports Alerts in your inbox:
Be the first to know the latest sports news as it happens.
Thank you for signing up! Sign up for more newsletters here

There are two things at play here: Valentine is not afraid to say what he really thinks in public. And former Red Sox manager Terry Francona never did.

Francona protected his players at all costs, even miscreants like Manny Ramirez or guys who showed him up on the field like John Lackey. No matter what the circumstances were, Francona would dodge the question or pretend he wasn’t upset.

That way worked for a long time. The Red Sox played hard for Francona and won two world titles. But in the end, it cost him his job because the players took advantage of his good will. Then in 2011, the Red Sox weren’t ready for the season to start and then they quit on each other at the end.

Valentine was hired to change that. When the team with the second-highest payroll in baseball finishes in third place for two years in a row, change is inevitable. Discomfort is inevitable. That’s the price the players have to pay for wrecking the good thing they had.


Calling out Youkilis, whether that was Valentine’s intention or not, was a mistake. The manager will likely learn how to pick his spots better than that.

But trying to shake up the Red Sox is not a mistake because they needed shaking up. When a team full of stars crash-lands in third place, you get Bobby Valentine and not Gene Lamont.

If Valentine can find a way to bring the passion back to the team without causing a ruckus every two weeks, it can work.

If not, this season could make 2011 look like the good old days.