scorecardresearch Skip to main content

Buffalo needed to fight, but proved too much for shorthanded Miami

Gabe Davis set Highmark Stadium alight late in the third quarter, his 23-yard touchdown connection with Josh Allen restoring Buffalo's double-digit lead after it surrendered a 17-0 edge to Eric Rowe (left) and Miami.Adrian Kraus/Associated Press

ORCHARD PARK, N.Y. — Josh Allen and the Buffalo Bills opened the season with Super Bowl aspirations. One week into the playoffs, their objective remains in sight, but barely.

Allen shrugged off a three-turnover outing, and the three-time defending AFC East champion Bills avoided a major collapse by rallying to pull out a 34-31 victory over the AFC’s seventh-seeded and injury-depleted Miami Dolphins in a wild-card playoff on Sunday.

In acknowledging he was hardly at his best, Allen said all that mattered was the final score.

“One-week seasons, man, that’s it,” he said. “All that matters is surviving and advancing. Doesn’t matter how we win, it’s if we win.”


The “if” part of the equation hung in the balance until the final minutes of a game in which the Bills squandered a 17-0 lead against an opponent that limped into the playoffs by losing five of its final six and was down to its third-string quarterback, rookie Skylar Thompson.

It wasn’t until Allen’s fumble was returned 5 yards for a touchdown by Zach Sieler 61 seconds into the third quarter to put the Dolphins up, 24-20, that the Bills offense finally reawakened.

Allen threw two touchdown passes over a span of 3:11, with Cole Beasley scoring the go-ahead TD with a 6-yard catch, before Gabe Davis extended the lead to 34-24 with a 23-yard TD reception.

“That’s just playoff football for the most part. All the games I’ve played in the playoffs, I don’t even know if we’ve had a blowout,” Beasley said. “The thing is you’ve got to keep your foot on the gas. You can’t ever get complacent. You gotta play consistent. We were a little inconsistent tonight. We can’t do that going forward.”

The game wasn’t decided until Buffalo’s defense, which forced six punts and two turnovers, stopped Miami as it turned the ball over on downs on its final possession. Thompson’s pass on fourth and 6 went just off the fingertips of tight end Mike Gesicki with 2:22 remaining.


Buffalo, which closed the season reeling off seven straight victories, ran out the clock when Devin Singletary bulled his way for a 7-yard gain to convert a third and 7.

It was a sloppy game and a lengthy saga lasting nearly four hours between two division rivals, and the outcome was fitting after the two teams split their regular-season series in games decided by a combined 5 points. Allen finished 23 of 39 for 352 yards and three TDs, but also threw two interceptions which resulted in the Dolphins scoring 11 points.

Buffalo advances to host the third-seeded Cincinnati Bengals, who beat Baltimore on Sunday night. Kansas City will come off the bye to face Jacksonville.

The Dolphins played tough in a game they entered as 13½-point underdogs, according to FanDuel Sportsbook, without numerous offensive starters, including quarterback Tua Tagovailoa, who is still in the concussion protocol, and backup Teddy Bridgewater, who is dealing with a dislocated pinkie finger.

“That was the hand that was dealt, and that was part of the story, that we were willing to complete,” coach Mike McDaniel said. “I’m heartbroken for the guys because they didn’t want their season to end and they did everything they could.”

The Dolphins extended their run of playoff loses to five. Miami’s most recent playoff win was a 23-17 overtime victory over Indianapolis on Dec. 30, 2000, in the wild-card round.


Miami’s defense and special teams made up for an offense that managed just 16 first downs and 231 yards. Jevon Holland and Xavien Howard’s interceptions, along with Cedric Wilson’s 50-yard punt return, led to the Dolphins taking advantage of short fields to tie the game at 17 on Gesicki’s 7-yard catch late in the second quarter.

Making just his third career start, Thompson finished 18 of 45 for 220 yards with a touchdown and two interceptions.

“Man, our defense played so good today. That’s tough. Because those guys gave us every chance to win,” Thompson said. “Feel like that’s a game we definitely had the opportunity to win. I will take [responsibility] for the loss, and shoulder that, and move forward.”