fb-pixel

On Sunday, Boston Chamber Music Society presents a program including Franz Schubert’s “Der Hirt auf dem Felsen” (“The Shepherd on the Rock”), for soprano, clarinet, and piano, a rare Schubert lied written specifically for concert rather than salon performance. Anna-Milder Hauptmann, a leading prima donna in Vienna and Berlin, admired Schubert’s songs, but asked the composer for something more “suitable for a large audience.” After several years’ procrastination, Schubert finished the piece in October 1828.

“Der Hirt auf dem Felsen” dressed an old trope in up-to-date fashion. That trope was the pastoral: gentle lyrics of nymphs and shepherds already epitomized in ancient times by the Roman poet Virgil’s Eclogues. The fashion was Romanticism: The shepherd is now Byronically alone, in a characteristically forbidding landscape.

Advertisement



The text of “Der Hirt auf dem Felsen” mixed portions of poems by Karl August Varnhagen von Ense and Wilhelm Müller — political liberals both. Varnhagen was a diplomat whose republican enthusiasms caused friction with his increasingly authoritarian Prussian bosses. Müller’s political writings frequently encountered official censorship; even his seemingly benign lyrics often reveal political dimensions with a little hermeneutical prodding. Is there such a dimension in “Der Hirt auf dem Felsen”? The work’s final section exuberantly insists, through Müller’s poem “Liebesgedanken,” that “spring will come,” a seasonal renewal that might symbolize any long-awaited arrival: of love, freedom, democracy, peace.

That is, undoubtedly, a stretch (even poetically, given the breeziness of “Liebesgedanken”), but the stretch has precedent. For centuries, the pastoral was a political arena-by-proxy. Medieval and Renaissance critics mined Virgil’s Eclogues (particularly the fourth, cryptically referencing a long-awaited birth) for harbingers — and justifications — of Christian theocracy.

Even 17th-century French prescriptions for an abstract, anodyne pastoral, scholar Annabel Patterson has pointed out, concealed nervous conservatism; for a Romantic example, Patterson cites Robert John Thornton’s 1821 schoolbook edition of eclogues by Virgil and others, with illustrations by William Blake — both, in their own way, implicitly critiquing divisions wrought by the Industrial Revolution. Virgil’s Eclogues themselves were permeated with contemporary politics: the Roman civil war that followed Julius Caesar’s assassination, and the hope of postwar restoration. Pastorals were often the poetic equivalent of a cornfield in a campaign ad.

Advertisement



That’s probably not what Schubert intended. But Schubert probably didn’t intend “Der Hirt auf dem Felsen” to be as poignant as it turned out, either. He died just a month after finishing it, never seeing the following spring the song so ebulliently anticipates.


Matthew Guerrieri can be reached at matthewguerrieri@gmail.com.