Salem residents angry over museum’s plan to move historical records

Salem,MA-12/1/98- Original document from the Salem witch trial.
Wendy Maeda/globe staff
Documents from the Salem witch trials are among the records that would be housed in another community.

Salem is best known for the witch trials, but it was also a vitally important seaport in the Colonial economy and the hometown of Nathaniel Hawthorne, who took early inspiration for “The Scarlet Letter’’ and “The House of the Seven Gables’’ there.

Now, angry residents say, a plan by the Peabody Essex Museum threatens to cut the city’s link to its proud history.

The museum is preparing to move permanently a vast collection of the city’s historical records to a facility in another town and turn portions of the buildings that housed the museum’s Phillips Library into office space for the fast- growing museum.


The fate of the collection — which includes transcripts from the witch trials, Hawthorne’s papers, and records from some of Salem’s most prominent merchant families — has struck a chord in this city that once played an outsized role on the world stage, but now teems with tchotchke shops hocking crystals to tourists.

Get The Weekender in your inbox:
The Globe's top picks for what to see and do each weekend, in Boston and beyond.
Thank you for signing up! Sign up for more newsletters here

At a sometimes rocky forum Thursday night, hundreds of people piled into the museum’s atrium to discuss the move, which opponents say is nothing shy of a showdown for the soul of Salem.

“This is Salem’s identity,” said resident Donald Friary, president of the Colonial Society of Massachusetts. “This is not just a witch city. This is a historical city with a great maritime history that dates from the dawn of the global age.”

Dan Monroe, PEM’s director and CEO, who presided over the meeting, called the notion that the city’s identity is bound up in its documentary history nonsense, and said the move is necessary to preserve the collection, which spans well beyond Salem’s history to include historical documents from Essex County and beyond.

“It sounds like a meaningful statement, but history doesn’t reside in a specific state or a specific set of documents,” said Monroe. “The reality on the ground is that there’s no way to return the Phillips collection to Salem. It’s an unfortunate reality, but there it is.”


The library, which has had several incarnations with roots stretching back to at least 1799, has long served as Salem’s de facto historical society, said Donna Seger, who chairs the history department at Salem State University. The PEM has overseen the historical records since its 1992 creation with the merger of the Peabody Museum and the Essex Institute.

“There’s no assurance whatsoever that this most important Salem history — all the Hawthorne, all the witch trial stuff — there’s no assurance that any of that is staying in Salem,” said Seger. “This is not a necessity, it’s a choice.”

In fact, the contents of the Phillips Library have not been in Salem for years. The museum closed the library in 2011, moving its contents to a temporary facility in Peabody (where it was open to the public) as it modernized its catalog system.

The original plan, Monroe said, was to eventually return the collection to its historical home in Salem — a pair of 19th-century structures and a later 1966 addition — once they’d been fully renovated.

“We simply didn’t foresee that we legally had to make all parts of those buildings compliant with current codes,” Monroe said. “That includes this 1966 addition that’s completely idiosyncratic: There’s no way that one can make it comply with current building codes.”


Instead, Monroe said, the museum has decided to house the library’s contents permanently in a 100,000-plus-square-foot facility about 15 miles away in Rowley. The 1966 addition will be torn down, and the two historical buildings — Plummer Hall and Daland House — will be used for office space, while the historical reading room will remain open to the public and be used for museum functions.

“The ultimate issue is the necessity to make preservation of this incredibly important collection our highest priority,” Monroe said. “It would never be possible in an even remotely realistic way to create facilities in Salem to house those collections.”

Although the museum mentioned that it would create the collections facility when it first announced the expansion in 2015, many in Salem said they were only made aware of the plan to move the library there late last year, when PEM representatives approached the town’s historical commission about altering the library buildings.

“At that meeting it came out that the collection was being moved to Rowley,” said Jessica Herbert, who chairs the Salem Historical Commission. “No one had ever heard anything about this before.”

Monroe said the museum was not trying to hide anything, noting that the library only hosts about 900 visitors each year with “very few of them from Salem.” He added that the museum did not acquire the new building for the collections center until March of last year.

“There was an expectation by a number of people that we had a responsibility to consult with them about what would be done with the Phillips collection,” said Monroe. “That’s an expectation that we didn’t particularly share or understand.”

Friary said the museum holds its collections in the public trust and has a duty to be open about its operations.

“The word we heard over and over again was transparency,” he said. “No one in Salem knew this was happening. No one knew they were looking for other sites. . . . There is a very high level of mistrust.”

Malcolm Gay can be reached at Follow him on Twitter at @malcolmgay