US stands by response to 787 events

All Nippon Airways grounded its fleet of Boeing 787s voluntarily after a battery failed in flight. Overall, 50 Dreamliners have been grounded worldwide.
Koji Sasahara/Associated Pres
All Nippon Airways grounded its fleet of Boeing 787s voluntarily after a battery failed in flight. Overall, 50 Dreamliners have been grounded worldwide.

WASHINGTON — Obama administration officials struggled Wednesday to defend their initial statements that the Boeing 787 Dreamliner is safe while promising a transparent probe of mishaps involving the aircraft’s batteries.

Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood stood by his Jan. 11 assertion that the 787, Boeing’s newest and most technologically advanced airliner, was safe. At that time, LaHood and the head of the Federal Aviation Administration, Michael Huerta, declared the plane fit to fly despite a battery fire in one plane.

Five days later, following another battery mishap that led to an emergency landing of a 787 in Japan, LaHood and Huerta ordered United, the lone US carrier with 787s, to ground the planes. Authorities in Europe and elsewhere — including Chile, Poland, Ethiopia, Qatar, and India — swiftly followed suit. Two Japanese airlines voluntarily grounded their planes before the FAA’s order.


Overall, 50 Dreamliners have been grounded worldwide. The FAA’s order applies only to United’s the six 787s.

Get Talking Points in your inbox:
An afternoon recap of the day’s most important business news, delivered weekdays.
Thank you for signing up! Sign up for more newsletters here

‘‘On the day we announced the planes were safe they were,’’ LaHood told reporters at an aviation industry luncheon. He became testy when a reporter pressed him on whether his initial pronouncements had been too hasty.

‘‘I’m not doing these hypothetical look-backs,’’ he said. ‘‘We did what we did.’’

What changed between Jan. 11 and FAA’s issuance of a grounding order on Jan. 16 was that a second battery failure occurred on an All Nippon Airways 787 while the airliner was in flight, said Huerta, who joined LaHood at the luncheon. In the first incident, the battery fire occurred in a Japan Airlines 787 that had already landed at Boston’s Logan International Airport and was empty of passengers.

‘‘We took the action we took (to ground the planes) because we saw a hazard,’’ Huerta said.


The National Transportation Safety Board is also investigating the battery fire in Boston and has sent a representative to Japan to assist authorities there with their investigation of the second. The board has not so far said the battery problem would endanger the safety of the plane in flight nor recommended that the planes be grounded.

Meanwhile, the Japanese investigation into the battery from the flight in Japan has found no evidence that the battery was overcharged, a top aviation safety official said Wednesday.

Japanese investigators who retrieved the charred and disfigured battery pack from the All Nippon plane initially suspected overcharging, a dangerous condition where a battery is charged beyond its electrical capacity and becomes susceptible to overheating and fire.

But data retrieved from the All Nippon jet suggested that the battery had not been charged beyond its maximum design voltage, 32 volts, Norihiro Goto, chairman of the Japanese Transport Safety Board, told reporters Wednesday. The US Federal Aviation Administration announced similar findings Sunday from its investigation into the lithium-ion battery that caught fire in Boston.

The FAA is working as quickly as possible to find the cause of the problems, assembling a technical team that includes experts from industry as well as the agency’s staff, Huerta said. The review includes not just the 787’s lithium-ion battery system, but how that system works with the aircraft’s electronic systems, their certification, manufacture and assembly, he said.


Huerta declined to say when FAA might lift the grounding order.

The officials emphasized that the investigation would be completely transparent so that the public will have confidence in the outcome.

LaHood denied that Boeing had asked the government to lift the grounding order.

‘‘Absolutely not,’’ he said. ‘‘Boeing is cooperating 100 percent with the review.’’

The groundings have been a nightmare for Boeing, which competes with Airbus for the position as the world’s largest commercial aircraft maker. At the time of the groundings, Boeing had orders for more than 800 of the planes from airlines around the world attracted by the 787’s increased fuel efficiency. The aircraft maker has said it has stopped delivering new planes to customers, although it is continuing to build them.