Is Boston area on its way to another housing bubble?
As housing prices soar, some fear a corrective burst
Home prices are soaring in many communities, open houses are packed, and bidding wars are back in style, which all raises the question: Is Massachusetts headed toward another housing bubble?
A recent report by a Florida property valuation firm suggests that Massachusetts is among the places — 13 states and the District of Columbia — where home prices are rising far faster than the cost of building or renting a home. The widening gap could be an early warning sign that the state is creeping back into another bubble, said David Macpherson, an economist with Smithfield & Wainwright, which values real state for regulatory agencies and financial institutions.
"It's not back to where they were in 2006," said Macpherson, referring to the peak nationally of the last housing boom, "but it's starting to show the early signs of it."
The relationship between sales prices and rent and replacement costs provides a better understanding of the underlying value of the property and not just what a buyer is willing to pay, according to Smithfield & Wainwright. At the peak of the housing boom, prices in Massachusetts were about double the rental and replacement value of homes.
The gap narrowed quickly when the housing bubble burst, but it has widened in recent years. At the bottom of the market, for example, Massachusetts home prices were about 17 percent above replacement costs. Last year, the gap grew to 32 percent. (Nationally, the gap is about 5 percent.)
This could be a formula for another housing crash, similar to what hit a decade ago, when lenders agreed to mortgages that were far higher than what the properties were worth or what homeowners could afford, Macpherson said.
But some housing specialists say that while home prices are rising, they haven't become frothy. Home prices in some sought-after municipalities have appreciated as much as 80 percent since the peak of the housing market in 2005, but those in many other places have not recovered yet, said Timothy Warren, chief executive of Warren Group, a Boston real estate tracking firm.
Statewide, the median price in 2014 was $330,000, or about 7 percent lower than the peak of $355,000 in 2005, Warren said.
"There's still room to grow," he said. "Maybe there are bubbles in some of those communities. On a statewide basis, I don't think there is any risk of a bubble."
In the Boston area, a tight supply of homes on the market and pent-up demand have combined to drive prices up quickly, said Rachel Hillman, a Newton realtor. But unlike a decade ago, buyers are seeking places to live, rather speculative investments to flip, she said.
"People are making smarter decisions in terms of finding the right mortgage products," she said. "People are living within their means."
David M. Blitzer, managing director of the index committee at S&P Dow Jones Indices, which publishes the S&P/Case-Shiller Home Price Index, said if the Boston area's housing rebound continues at this pace, prices could hit new highs later this year.
Hogan Copeland, chairman of Smithfield & Wainwright, said the danger is that prices will become unsustainable. "Pricing of homes cannot outrun incomes," he said.