scorecardresearch Skip to main content

Treasurer says pension fund can’t divest its gun stocks without legislative action

State Treasurer Deborah B. Goldberg, left, with Ruth Ellen Fitch of the state pension board. Suzanne Kreiter/Globe staff/file

State Treasurer Deborah Goldberg says she cannot press the $60 billion Massachusetts state pension fund that she chairs to divest from gun stocks without action by lawmakers.

“While I am personally against owning gun stocks,’’ Goldberg said in a statement in the wake of the Orlando nightclub massacre Sunday, divestment from the state fund “has to be a directive from the Legislature.”

The Pension Reserves Investment Trust holds $2.2 million worth of publicly traded shares in two large gun manufacturers and a gun seller, including $465,000 in Springfield-based Smith & Wesson Holding Corp.

The sum is a drop in the bucket for the fund, just 0.2 percent of its total holdings. But the stocks have been profitable. Smith & Wesson and Sturm, Ruger & Co. of Southport, Conn., have vastly outperformed an index of similarly sized companies over the past year.


Like many pensions, endowments, and individuals saving for retirement, PRIM defers to the professional money managers of its index funds — those that own an entire list of stocks.

“PRIM staff leaves all divestment decisions to the Legislature,” said Eric Convey, a spokesman for the state pension fund.

Massachusetts lawmakers have previously passed measures requiring the fund to divest from tobacco companies and those that do business in South Africa and Sudan. But it’s a long process, at a time when many Americans are questioning whether they want to be profiting from guns.

“You buy the index. There’s no wiggle room on that,’’ said Amy Domini, founder and chair of Domini Social Investments, a $1.6 billion money manager based in New York that excludes weapons and other controversial investments from its funds.

Domini, coincidentally, grew up in Newtown, Conn., and attended the Sandy Hook Elementary School, where 26 children and adults were killed by a gunman in 2012. She also used guns herself on occasion: “Newtown was farm country then,’’ she said.


But she’s been excluding weapons from clients’ portfolios since the 1980s. Investing in guns, she said, “is visceral for a lot of people. They don’t want to feel that any little diminimus profit is coming to them from manufacturers of guns.”

Two of the nation’s largest and most influential public pension funds, the California Public Employees’ Retirement System and the California State Teachers’ Retirement System, elected to divest firearm stocks in 2013, after Sandy Hook. But many pensions and endowments have not taken such action.

Major endowments such as at Harvard University and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology declined to disclose their holdings in firearm companies. Those schools have faced protests from students, but mostly for investments in fossil fuel companies and other issues.

Deborah Azrael, research director of the Harvard Injury Control Research Center and an authority on guns, said she finds it concerning that gun stocks tend to rise after massacres like the one in Orlando.

“To me, the notion that Harvard’s endowment – any university’s endowment — goes up because of a non-fact-based fear that guns will be taken away from people in the wake of a mass shooting is abhorrent,’’ Azrael said.

“It feels ethically wrong to me,” Azrael said. “But I don’t have a fiduciary responsibility to maximize a return on investment.”

Gun and ammunition manufacturers generated $15 billion in revenue last year, according to IBIS World, a Los Angeles-based research firm. Gun and ammunition stores had $3.1 billion in sales.


On Thursday, Smith & Wesson reported a 31 percent jump in revenue, to $723 million, for its fiscal year ended in April and projected sales rising to as much as $760 million this year. Profits climbed 89 percent to $94 million.

“We believe in the long-term growth aspects of the market,’’ James Debney, the company’s chief executive, said on an earnings call with analysts.

Vanguard Group, the Valley Forge, Pa.-based investment firm with $3.5 trillion under management, is the largest owner of Smith & Wesson shares.

In a statement, spokeswoman Arianna Stefanoni Sherlock said, “Vanguard’s holdings in gun makers are predominantly in index funds, which are obligated to track benchmarks where manufacturers such as Smith & Wesson and Sturm, Ruger are represented.”

Beth Healy can be reached at Follow her on Twitter @HealyBeth.