Shutterstock / Africa Studio
A Massachusetts judge on Wednesday dismissed a beer importer’s lawsuit against the state’s largest distributor of craft beer, saying the importer waited too long to file its accusations of favoritism and underhanded business tactics.
Last year, Shelton Brothers Inc., a Belchertown firm that imports exotic beers from European breweries, sued Craft Brewers Guild, the Everett distributor implicated in the “pay-to-play” scandal roiling the state’s beer industry.
The importer alleged that Craft Brewers Guild raised the price of Shelton Brothers’ beers, letting them languish in its warehouse while illegally paying bars to stock other brews — and actively pushing competing European beers imported by another arm of Craft Brewers Guild’s parent company. Shelton Brothers also accused the wholesaler of reassigning salespeople it had promised would focus on Shelton Brothers products, and of harassing another wholesaler the importer started using when sales through Craft Brewers Guild fell.
But Hampshire Superior Court Judge John S. Ferrara ruled the statute of limitations had expired on the claims, which date to 2011 and earlier. He also said that Shelton Brothers’ request to sever its relationship with Craft Brewers Guild must first be adjudicated by the state Alcoholic Beverages Control Commission, or ABCC.
An attorney for Shelton Brothers said the importer would appeal the decision.
In addition to seeking $1.7 million in compensation for lost sales and permission to use another wholesaler, the complaint by Shelton Brothers doubled as a public indictment of the state’s controversial franchise law, under which alcohol suppliers such as brewers and importers are effectively bound to their distributors indefinitely after a six-month trial period.
Shelton Brothers and many brewers argue the system allows distributors to “hoard” suppliers without having to worry they will bolt for a competing wholesaler. Distributors believe the law protects their investments in promoting beer brands. The sides faced off last month at a State House hearing over proposed reforms to the law.
Mark Dickison, Craft Brewers Guild’s attorney, said his client was pleased with the outcome.
“Shelton Brothers was using Craft’s troubles with the ABCC to pile on and use as leverage in their relationship,” Dickison said. “The court correctly found that, if they really had this list of ills going on, they should have filed when it first occurred.”
On Monday, a state judge in Boston upheld the $2.6 million fine Craft Brewers Guild paid to avoid a three-month license suspension in the pay-to-play case.
Formed by billionaire investor Warren Buffett, Amazon’s Jeff Bezos, and JPMorgan Chase CEO Jamie Dimon, the company will be led by Brigham and Women’s surgeon Dr. Atul Gawande.Continue reading »
The wide-ranging “grand bargain’’ bill would also impose a small payroll tax on workers and employers to pay for the leaves.Continue reading »
After operating in the Seaport since early 2017 with no safety issues, NuTonomy Inc. received approval to send its vehicles into the rest of Boston.Continue reading »
Retailers in Massachusetts often complain that their concerns aren’t heard on Beacon Hill. Well, legislative leaders are listening now.Continue reading »
The high cost of housing in the region is forcing some recent college graduates to move back in with mom and dad to save money.Continue reading »
How do I address a letter to a husband and wife when the wife is a PhD and the husband is just Mr.? Would it be Mr. & Dr. or Dr. & Mr.?Continue reading »
A Cambridge company hopes it has the right ingredients to make “sous vide” appliances a countertop staple.Continue reading »
Three decades ago, Jack Little made a fateful decision to move his software startup from Silicon Valley to Massachusetts in search of engineering talent.Continue reading »
Wendy Schmidt and her husband, Eric Schmidt, the executive chairman of Google, are backing the RV Falkor in Woods Hole.Continue reading »