EVAN HOROWITZ | QUICK STUDY
Evan Vucci/Associated Press
It’s more than a new year, it’s a whole new regime for employers and workers, who have to make sense of the major tax changes Congress passed in December.
Starting in February, most workers will see a much-appreciated bump in their paychecks as a result of these tax cuts. But over time those benefits will shrink, and after eight years they’ll disappear, when key provisions expire.
And that helps drive home a key point: Tax cuts are a poor substitute for raises.
Let’s imagine ourselves as a typical breadwinner in Massachusetts, with a salary of about $80,000. Under the old tax system, we could expect to keep about $55,000, after accounting for local, state, and federal taxes.
Under the new law, though, our take-home pay jumps to $56,000, an increase of about 1.8 percent, according to calculations from the nonpartisan Tax Policy Center. That’s not nothing — who would turn down an extra $1,000? — but it’s probably not life-altering, either.
Especially when you consider this won’t be the only change in our paychecks.
Lots of us will also see our health insurance premiums go up. In recent years, employee premiums have been steadily rising all over the country, enough to cut our take-home pay by roughly $200, which would wipe out a chunk of the expected tax benefit.
Then there’s the question of whether we get a raise this year. When the economy is growing and the labor market is tight — as ours has been for years now — average wages should be increasing around 3.5 percent per year.
Unfortunately, typical workers haven’t been seeing these gains. Instead, wages have been growing between 2 and 2.5 percent per year. That means such workers as us — typical breadwinners in Massachusetts — are getting raises worth $1,300 instead of $2,000, after taxes.
Taken at face value, that missing $700 seems to be more than compensated for by the $1,000 tax break. But there’s a big difference here: Wage growth compounds. Raises happen every year, so we wouldn’t just get that extra $700 this year but a $1,400 boost the next year, and so on.
If we could get wages growing robustly again, our take-home pay in 2025 would be as much as $5,000 higher.
Tax cuts don’t work like this.
By 2025, our $1,000 pay bump is actually slated to shrink to around $700. There’s no compounding, as you have with wages.
And several of the biggest benefits for middle-income families — including the greatly expanded child tax credit and the larger standard deduction — are tied to a new, slower-growing inflation adjuster, so they won’t keep up with costs quite as well.
Then, come 2026, even this modest tax benefit may disappear, because many of the most worker-friendly elements are set to expire — unless a future Congress extends them.
The takeaway here isn’t really about the limited impact of the Republican tax plan, only its limited effect on middle-income workers. For corporations and big investors, the benefits are much larger, and they don’t expire.
But for people who earn paychecks — rather than profits — this doesn’t help much. They may, over time, be able to bargain for a share of the corporate gains, but the estimates used above already try to account for this trickle-down effect.
In the new post-tax-cut world, the biggest issue for workers’ welfare hasn’t really changed: It isn’t so much what the federal government does to provide tax cuts, but what employers deliver in terms of rising wages.
Amid this hodgepodge of older one- and two-story buildings, Robert Korff sees a golden opportunity for a modern version of the Garden City.Continue reading »
Nearly 5,000 teaching and research assistants join the United Auto Workers, a union with blue-collar roots that has become a bastion of academic organizingContinue reading »
One woman’s story proves that you can never save too much.Continue reading »
Aging Americans are getting so many new hips, knees, shoulders, and ankles that orthopedic surgeons are having trouble handling demand.Continue reading »
For hundreds of thousands of people in Massachusetts, many of whom are hungry and isolated, Meals on Wheels is a daily human connection to the outside world.Continue reading »
The little-known company, a comparison shopping site for auto insurance, looks almost nothing like a hot consumer technology firm.Continue reading »
Boston’s economic disparities are well-documented, but newer mapping tools display inequalities in stark visual contrast.Continue reading »
As the #MeToo movement and public outcry about the treatment of women spreads, corporate America is slowly responding.Continue reading »
As graduation season gets underway, here are some tips to make that post-grad job interview a successful one.Continue reading »