Ask Amy

Ask Amy column

Q. We have a neighbor we have helped in many ways — friendship, taking her shopping, bringing over baked treats, and stepping in, in emergency situations.

This neighbor now seems to think we are her go-to people for everything. She has a son who lives nearby, but he seems to not show up much.

I blew up a few weeks ago when I was dealing with my own problems and told her I can’t be everything to everyone. She apologized and said she understood. But it hasn’t stopped.


My husband doesn’t really deal with her on the same level and now he makes me feel guilty when I can’t tolerate being her problem solver anymore.

Get The Weekender in your inbox:
The Globe's top picks for what to see and do each weekend, in Boston and beyond.
Thank you for signing up! Sign up for more newsletters here

The stress gives me headaches. She had a very good and interesting job, traveled the world, and yet has not an ounce of common sense.

Not My

Neighbor’s Keeper

A. Your kindness has conditioned your needy neighbor to rely on you for everyday — and emergency — help.

Blowing up suddenly because you feel used will not retrain your neighbor. It will only make her think that you are volatile.

I assume you think you don’t owe her anything further, but you do owe her a respectful and rational explanation, along with guidelines to which you will adhere — even if she doesn’t.


Tell her, “I can’t do the things for you that I used to. You’re going to have to find other ways to get what you need, day-to-day.” Research options for elder transportation or services. But unless she is unusually impaired, it will be her responsibility to follow through. You should also follow up with her son to let him know you are backing off.

If she calls you with a non-emergency matter, you should tell her, “I’m sorry, I can’t help out today.” Stepping back might give you more energy to step in when she really needs you.

Q. I would like to date my sister’s sister-in-law.

When I expressed my romantic interest to her, she said that our families were too close and she would not want any resentment if it didn’t work out.

I’ve tried the platonic approach but the friendship wasn’t reciprocated. Any advice?

Crushed Sibling


A. If you express romantic interest in someone and she rebuffs you, then you need to back off.

If you express platonic friendship interest in someone and she doesn’t reciprocate, then you have a definitive answer: She is not at all into you.

Q. Your recent advice regarding the emotional distress caused by surprises in wills made me think of my recently departed mother.

While she was in good health more than a decade ago, she sat down with me and my three siblings to share her final wishes, neatly organized in a three-ring binder which she updated annually. Her current will, Do Not Resuscitate document, bank/investment statements, and insurance policies were included, as were her wishes for her funeral.

Everything from the dress she saved to be buried in to the readings and music were included, and she did so with humor.

Her pre-planning and the transparency of her final wishes made things incredibly easy on us, and — despite the sadness of her passing — we were able to draw strength, comfort, and even chuckles from the notes she left for us, allowing us to truly celebrate her life while we mourned her death.

As a result, the four of us have all created our own binders patterned after hers.


A. This is a fantastic idea.

Amy Dickinson can be reached at Follow her on Twitter @askingamy or “like” her on Facebook.