‘Green Book’ wins Producers Guild of America award, amid controversies
“Green Book” chronicles a road trip that, while fraught and contentious, ultimately pays dividends for those involved.
The film’s award-season run has been just as bumpy and rewarding.
Saturday night in Beverly Hills, Calif., the Producers Guild of America gave Peter Farrelly’s racial-issues comedy its top prize, a win that opens a clear path for “Green Book” to potentially take the Academy Award for best picture. Only twice since the academy expanded the best-picture field a decade ago have the two organizations differed on a winner. (That would be 2017, when “La La Land” won the PGA and “Moonlight” took the Oscar; and 2016, when the producers crowned “The Big Short” and the Oscar went to “Spotlight.”)
The victory for “Green Book,” over heavy hitters like “Roma” and “A Star Is Born,” surprised many in the Beverly Hilton ballroom, not least of all Farrelly, whose best-known film was previously “Dumb and Dumber.”
“It’s my first time at the PGA Awards, and the first time I ever heard of the PGA Awards,” Farrelly joked during his acceptance speech.
After taking the Golden Globe for best comedy or musical earlier this month, “Green Book” now has two significant honors to its name. Still, the 1962-set film about the budding friendship between virtuoso black pianist Don Shirley (Mahershala Ali) and his white driver, Tony Vallelonga (Viggo Mortensen), has faced more controversies than any other major awards contender this season.
Let’s take a deep breath before running through them all. First, Shirley’s family members disputed the facts of the film and said they were not consulted about it, which prompted Ali to reach out with an apology. Meanwhile, Mortensen had to issue a statement apologizing for using the “N-word” at a post-film Q&A.
More recently, Farrelly came under fire for his frequent habit of jokingly flashing his genitals to colleagues, while co-writer Nick Vallelonga (son of the film’s protagonist) deleted his Twitter account after internet sleuths found an anti-Muslim tweet he had made in 2015. (Ali, who many expect will win the supporting-actor Oscar next month, is Muslim.)
Still, the film’s award-season trajectory suggests it has weathered these controversies unscathed. The older, more traditional industry voters whom “Green Book” counts as its core audience are also the least likely to be affected by or even cognizant of the film’s PR snafus.
The academy has taken great pains in recent years to diversify its membership, but in a year when many filmmakers of color told acclaimed stories like “Black Panther,” “If Beale Street Could Talk,” “BlacKkKlansman” and “Crazy Rich Asians,” it may still be “Green Book” — a racial-issues movie written and directed by white men — that proves to be the ultimate winner.
“I don’t need awards,” Farrelly said near the end of his PGA acceptance speech. “This award, to me, is like Warren Buffett winning the lottery.”
With the Oscars next month, we’ll soon see if the rich get richer.