Group challenges N.E. energy policy

HARTFORD — A Boston environmental group is challenging how energy policy is coordinated by New England’s six governors, saying they are conducting private negotiations with the energy industry.

The Conservation Law Foundation has submitted public records requests in the six states. It said a plan by the governors that focuses on natural gas and hydropower from Canada ‘‘appears to be the product of backroom deal-making, rather than sound public policy informed by open dialogue.’’

The group’s vice president of policy and climate advocacy, Seth Kaplan, said, ‘‘Without vital public transparency, the resulting projects are sure to cost more than they should, in dollars as well as environmental impact.’’


The governors announced late last year a plan to expand natural gas use. They asked the region’s grid operator, ISO-New England, for technical help to seek proposals to build transmission equipment and public works to deliver electricity to as many as 3.6 million homes. They also asked ISO to figure out how to finance the project.

Get Fast Forward in your inbox:
Forget yesterday's news. Get what you need today in this early-morning email.
Thank you for signing up! Sign up for more newsletters here

Christopher Recchia, head of Vermont’s Public Service Department, said officials have been transparent since unveiling the initiative and future actions will be ‘‘entirely public.’’

Dennis Schain, spokesman for the Connecticut Department of Energy and Environmental Policy, and Krista Selmi, spokeswoman for the Massachusetts Executive Office of Energy and Environmental Affairs, said the governors have had a policy of openness. They issued a statement in December, published their request to ISO-New England for assistance in January and initiated a comment process this month.

‘‘You don’t need to look any further than the price spikes for electricity in the Northeast this winter to appreciate the pressing need for action to correct decades of inactivity when it came to expanding both regional electric transmission capability and natural gas pipeline capacity to supply power plants,’’ Schain said.

Patrick Woodcock, director of the Maine governor’s energy office, said the states have solicited information from numerous groups and he denied that officials have negotiated privately with the energy industry.


Behind the Conservation Law Foundation’s criticism is its difference with governors over what it believes is an overreliance on natural gas. It is touted as less expensive than heating oil, but the drilling method used to draw out natural gas known as fracking is denounced by environmentalists.

‘‘The assumption which seems to be going on here is that we need a great new pipeline that must be paid for by the customers of New England through our electricity bills,’’ Kaplan said. ‘‘That assumption we think is wrong and at the very least needs to be tested in public.’’