fb-pixel Skip to main content

Bishop M. Thomas Shaw, former Episcopal leader; at 69

Bishop Thomas Shaw retired earlier this year.
Bishop Thomas Shaw retired earlier this year.David L. Ryan/Globe Staff/File 2013

Soft-spoken and clad in a subdued black robe of his monastic order, the Right Rev. M. Thomas Shaw seemed an unlikely choice in 1994 to lead one of the largest Episcopal dioceses in the nation. Yet his unswerving devotion to spirituality and his unwillingness to avoid political controversy turned him into one of the most visible and vocal religious leaders of his time.

"Ever since I was a little boy I wanted to do the will of God," Bishop Shaw told the Globe two years into his 20-year tenure as head of the Episcopal Diocese of Massachusetts.

Diagnosed with brain cancer nearly a year and a half ago, Bishop Shaw died Friday in West Newbury in Emery House, part of the monastic community of his order, the Society of St. John the Evangelist. He was 69.


"Tom Shaw was a genuinely unique spiritual presence in the City of Boston and certainly in the Episcopal Diocese," said the Rev. Samuel T. Lloyd III, rector of Trinity Church in Boston. "There has not been one quite like him. His imprint has been comprehensive and will be lasting."

For Bishop Shaw, once called upon to be a leader, fulfilling the will of God meant becoming a citizen of the world far beyond the doors of the serene monastery on Memorial Drive in Cambridge that was his home for nearly four decades. Though he preferred the life of a monk, he appeared in national TV interviews, lobbied State House officials, worked as an unpaid congressional intern, traveled to distant dangerous lands, and created programs to address urban violence, particularly among the young.

He also went online with "Monk in the midst: Bishop Shaw's blog." Still, his presence always reflected his background, and he wore his monastic garb whether riding the T to his downtown Boston office or walking through Washington's halls of power.


"Not only was he a monk, he was a pretty quiet monk, and yet he had such a public impact," Lloyd said. "He embodied his faith in a radical way. Tom was, I'd say, recklessly courageous in praying deeply about what he was called to do, and then simply doing it. He stood firmly amid many of the major societal shifts of our time and often was at the forefront of them."

Among Boston's most powerful clergy, Bishop Shaw was an early, key advocate for gay rights and for the ordination of women, gays, and lesbians as priests in his denomination, and in a 2012 interview for a documentary, he let it be known that he was gay and celibate. Long before making his sexuality public, he guided his diocese through a stormy decade while a conflicted Episcopal Church decided whether it would consecrate a gay bishop and allow clergy to bless same-gender unions.

"The life of the church is always enhanced by including people that live on the margins of society – women, people of color, gay or lesbian people," he told the Globe in 1997. "They have something profound to say about the Kingdom of God and they are the people Jesus specifically included among his disciples."

At the same time, Bishop Shaw remained sensitive to conservative opponents of gay marriage at home and abroad. Even while advocating forcefully for gay rights within his denomination and beyond, he waited more than five years after Massachusetts legalized gay marriage in 2004 before giving priests permission to officiate at same-gender weddings.


"I have a longstanding reputation for supporting gay and lesbian rights, both in society and in the church, and I was surprised and delighted when the Supreme Judicial Court made its decision," he told the Globe in 2004. "But this is one place where the state is ahead of the life of the church."

He was a leading supporter of elevating an openly gay priest, V. Gene Robinson, to become bishop of New Hampshire. Nonetheless, to better grasp the deeply held opposition some cultures have to homosexuality, Bishop Shaw went to Africa in the late 1990s and immersed himself in the Episcopal Church's health and education projects in Uganda and Tanzania.

A decade later, he traveled to Zimbabwe on a secret mission to express support for Anglican worshippers who were subjected to human rights abuses and to bear witness to their suffering through letters to US officials back home. "I don't think I've ever been any place where the oppression has been that overt," Bishop Shaw told the Globe upon his return.

To see close up how public policy is forged, he moved to Washington, D.C., in early 2000 and spent a month as a congressional intern working for Amory Houghton Jr., an Episcopalian and a Republican who was then a US representative from New York and now lives in Cohasset.

The following year, Bishop Shaw incurred the ire of Jewish leaders when he joined others outside the Israeli consulate in Boston to protest that country's treatment of Palestinians. Uncharacteristically, he traded his monk's garb for a purple cassock that announced the gravitas of a bishop. His participation surprised many Jews, and he subsequently spent years mending the rift through discussions with leaders in the Jewish community.


"It takes a lot to admit, 'I may have hurt you, and I want to understand why what I did or said hurt you,'" Rabbi Eric Gurvis of Temple Shalom in West Newton, a past president of the Massachusetts Board of Rabbis, told the Globe in 2013.

Not all Jewish leaders were soothed by his entreaties, though, and Bishop Shaw continued to speak out for Palestinian rights.

Discussing his political activism in January 2013, when he announced plans to retire before learning he was ill, Bishop Shaw invoked the life of Jesus. "He was very out there in terms of critiquing a society that didn't recognize the dignity of human beings," he told the Globe. "And so I think because I'm a follower of Jesus, that's my responsibility as well – I'm supposed to speak up on issues that diminish people's dignity."

Born in Battle Creek, Mich., on Aug. 28, 1945, Marvil Thomas Shaw III grew up in a devout family and believed early on that he would give his life over to God.

"The church was always at the center of my life," he told the Globe in 1997.


He graduated from Alma College in Alma, Mich., and received master's degrees from the General Theological Seminary in New York City and Catholic University of America in Washington, D.C.

After being ordained to the priesthood in 1971, he was a curate at the Church of St. Mary the Virgin in Higham Ferrers, Northamptonshire, England, and then assistant rector of St. James Church in Milwaukee.

He entered the Society of St. John the Evangelist in 1975 and seven years later was elected its superior, serving a 10-year term. While he was the order's leader, the diocese said, Bishop Shaw "was instrumental in developing the society's rural Emery House property as a retreat center, establishing the Cowley publishing imprint for books on prayer and spirituality, and renewing the society's longtime commitment to at-risk children in Boston through Camp St. Augustine in Foxborough."

When he was elected bishop in 1994, he was 48 and was the first monk in the church's history to serve in that position. Then and until not long before his death, he lived in the order's monastery on Memorial Drive, a short walk from Harvard Square in Cambridge. His home was a small cell in the monastery, and he managed to pray 90 minutes a day, even after taking on greater responsibilities as head of the diocese. "I wouldn't have the perspective I have on my struggles if I didn't pray," he told the Globe in 1996.

Those struggles began early when he was elected bishop. Serving initially alongside his predecessor, Bishop David E. Johnson, Bishop Shaw guided the diocese through tragedy and tumult when Johnson shot himself in January 1995. At the funeral, Bishop Shaw told mourners that "we know David fell in the struggle against despair."

Then, 11 days after announcing the suicide, Bishop Shaw was a co-signer of a statement the diocese issued explaining that Johnson "was involved in several extramarital relationships at different times throughout his years of ministry, both as a priest and bishop," including some that "appear to have been of the character of sexual exploitation." That Johnson had been viewed as a tough enforcer of rules against clergy sexual abuse added to the sense of betrayal many felt. "We don't want to keep anything hidden," Bishop Shaw told the Globe a few days after issuing the statement. "Knowing everything will help the healing begin."

During Bishop Shaw's tenure, among his proudest accomplishments were programs he created to serve youth and to help reduce urban violence. A diocesan camp and retreat center opened in Greenfield, N.H., in 2003, while in the South End, St. Stephen's Episcopal Church initiated the Bishop's Summer Academic and Fun Enrichment program, or B-SAFE, for hundreds of inner city youth. A graduate of the program, Jorge Fuentes, became a respected counselor and mentor, and his death by a stray bullet, across the street from his Dorchester home in 2012 was devastating for the diocese and Bishop Shaw, who presided over the 19-year-old's funeral.

Bishop Shaw's final blog post included a video of him speaking at the Mother's Day Walk for Peace in 2013, when he was part of a contingent of more than 600 Episcopalians who walked in memory of Fuentes.

"The presence of this spiritually grounded man of integrity was catalyzing," Lloyd said. "The diocese has grown profoundly in its strength and clarity, and its ministry has expanded in extraordinary ways. He was a transformational figure in the diocese. And for those of us who knew him and loved him, he was transformational in our own journey and what he showed us along the way."

When Bishop Shaw thought the time had arrived to address his sexuality publicly, he took an understated approach, doing so in an interview while being filmed for "Love Free or Die," a 2012 documentary about Robinson, who became the first openly gay bishop in the Episcopal Church when he led the New Hampshire diocese.

Bishop Shaw told the Globe he didn't want his choice to be a celibate monk to be held up as an example that lesbians and gays in the clergy should also choose celibacy.

"My hope has always been … that we can move along this discussion about human sexuality in the best possible way, and I thought for myself the best possible way I could move it along as a celibate bishop was not by hiding it, but by not making myself the center of the discussion," he said then.

Upon announcing his retirement, Bishop Shaw posted a letter on the diocesan website saying his decision emerged "from prayer and conversation with my community, friends, and family."

"I love being your bishop, and it is an honor to serve you," he wrote. "These years have been some of the richest years of my life. All of you and this work have taught me much about myself and the nature of our loving God for which I will always be grateful."

Funeral arrangements are pending for Bishop Shaw, who leaves a sister, Penny, of Louisville, Ky., and two brothers, Sam of Boulder, Colo., and Stephen of Sherwood, Ore.

In January 2013, he announced he would retire by year's end. A few months later, he said that he had brain cancer, and he began radiation and chemotherapy soon after.

The Rev. Geoffrey Tristram, superior of the Society of St. John the Evangelist, said in a statement that “during his last days, our brother Tom spoke of how very, very thankful he was for the life God had given him: for the many wonderful people he had met, for the opportunities and challenges he had faced, and for the amazing grace he had experienced throughout his life.”

Bryan Marquard
can be reached at bryan.marquard@globe.com.