Defense sought evidence from ‘11 triple slayings
A federal judge rejected a request by lawyers for accused Boston Marathon bomber Dzhokhar Tsarnaev to force prosecutors to turn over information about a Waltham triple-murder case, saying the requested information is not related to Tsarnaev’s defense.
US District Court Judge George A. O’Toole Jr. also refused to hold a hearing to investigate law enforcement leaks to the news media, as requested by the defense, saying such a hearing “is unlikely to be either productive or effective.”
“It is instead more likely to elicit further comment and speculation and distract from the proceedings,” O’Toole wrote in an order issued Tuesday.
Tsarnaev, now 21, is scheduled to go to trial in January for the April 15, 2013, bombings that killed three people and injured more than 260 near the Marathon’s finish line.
He and his older brother Tamerlan are also accused of killing an MIT police officer. Tamerlan was killed during a confrontation with police in Watertown.
Dzhokhar Tsarnaev faces the possibility of the death penalty if convicted.
In advance of Tsarnaev’s trial, defense lawyers have sought more information from the government to help present their case, such as copies of the government’s communications with Russian authorities about Tamerlan. O’Toole said the government has already provided what is necessary.
The judge also said he would not order prosecutors to turn over more information about an investigation into a triple homicide in Waltham in 2011.
One of Tamerlan’s friends, Ibragim Todashev, allegedly confessed that he and Tamerlan were involved in the killings. Todashev was shot and killed by an FBI agent in May 2013 after he allegedly attacked the agent during questioning at his apartment in Florida.
O’Toole said Tuesday that prosecutors have already provided enough information about the core issue — that Tamerlan was allegedly involved in the killings.
The judge said the requested information, part of an ongoing state investigation into the murders, would not advance the theory that Tamerlan was a murderer who intimidated and influenced his younger brother.
“I conclude that the report is not material and helpful in the necessary sense,” the judge said.
Defense lawyers had filed the request for a hearing into leaks to the media after a recent magazine article cited information from anonymous law enforcement officials.
O’Toole said he was concerned about the magazine report after recently warning prosecutors not to disclose information, though he acknowledged that prosecutors had sent a letter to law enforcement agencies in July alerting them of the judge’s warning.
“It is essential that those who were previously or are currently involved in the case, or who otherwise have access to nonpublic information, understand and appreciate the concerns addressed in the government’s letter, particularly as the commencement of trial draws closer,” O’Toole said.
He ordered government prosecutors to tell law enforcement supervisors to warn their subordinates that they could be sanctioned if they disclose information about the case to the news media.
Alexandra Valoras showed every outward sign of success and promise, a star at school, beloved at home. She revealed nothing of her inner anguish, except in her diary — a chronicle of scathing self-criticism and growing desperation that her parents chose to share so that other families might learn from their loss.Continue reading »
Along with his tenure as US poet laureate, Donald Hall was the winner of numerous honors and prizes in poetry, and was a member of the American Academy of Arts and Letters.Continue reading »
For 11 hours on Wednesday, drivers who wanted to travel through a remote stretch of northern Maine were asked a simple question: Where were you born?Continue reading »
These Emergency Response posts, tucked in trailers or nondescript government buildings, are staffed purely on an overtime basis.Continue reading »
The practice of arresting undocumented immigrants in government offices was halted by the region’s former acting director.Continue reading »
For Superintendent Tommy Chang, a failure at community-building stymied efforts to improve Boston’s public schools, education experts and city officials said.Continue reading »
More than a century after it opened as a museum, it remains an impressive glimpse into life during Colonial times, and the 1851 Nathaniel Hawthorne novel that the house inspired.Continue reading »
The leading German submarine commander of World War II brought U-boat warfare to the doorstep of New York Harbor in the winter of 1942.Continue reading »
Tommy Chang confirmed he will resign, and Boston Mayor Martin Walsh said the public school system needs a leader “who can gain the confidence of the community.”Continue reading »