When a federal judge from the Southern District of New York sided with Tom Brady in the Deflategate case in September, the legal odds seemed to be in favor of New England’s star quarterback.
Only 7.5 percent of the 1,667 civil cases that came out of the court were overturned on appeal between Aug. 1, 2013, and July 31, 2014, the Globe has reported.
The September court ruling that had gone in Brady’s favor was made by Judge Richard Berman, and the NFL’s appeal of that ruling moved the case to the US Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit in New York.
Berman himself has only had his decisions reversed or vacated by the Second Circuit about 8 percent of the time, according to an analysis published in Sports Illustrated by Michael McCann, head of the sports law program at the University of New Hampshire.
But Marc D. Greenbaum, a labor and employment professor from Suffolk University, said that when trying to predict the outcome of an individual case, such statistics are irrelevant.
“Yeah, there’s patterns,” he said. “But each case is different. I don’t believe in numbers when it comes to this.”
“I wasn’t surprised that Berman was overturned,” added Greenbaum, who described himself as a long-time Patriots fan. “I always thought his decision was vulnerable, and unfortunately I was right.”
The T on Monday will advance a sweeping proposal to remake a central component of the system that impacts nearly every rider: how we pay for rides.Continue reading »
Of the ripples from Donald Trump’s 2016 splash, Brown’s ascension to ambassador ranks among the most unlikely. And, for the former US senator, the most fortunate.Continue reading »
Despite allegations by an intern, a special agent in the Internal Revenue Service’s criminal investigation office in Boston has not been charged with any crimes.Continue reading »
A sleek, relatively new vaping device called a “Juul” has school administrators sending warning e-mails home.Continue reading »
The 5-year-old service dog came into Jessica Kensky and Patrick Downes’ lives after they were injured in the 2013 Boston Marathon bombing.Continue reading »
Four students attend Harvard University, two go to MIT, and one Massachusetts resident attends the Naval Academy in Maryland.Continue reading »
A Boston Marathon survivor’s journey as she debates whether to live with pain or become a double-amputee.Continue reading »
In November, Massachusetts voters are likely to consider a ballot question legalizing recreational marijuana.Continue reading »
About a hundred ralliers were on the Common Saturday, and several hundred counterprotesters came out. Police kept the groups separated.Continue reading »