Lane Turner/Globe Staff
A federal judge refused Tuesday to throw out extortion and conspiracy charges against two top aides to Boston Mayor Martin J. Walsh for allegedly pressuring the Boston Calling music festival to hire union workers in 2014.
US District Court Judge Leo T. Sorokin ruled in an 11-page order that the criminal case against Kenneth Brissette and Timothy Sullivan should proceed, rejecting defense claims their constitutional rights were being violated by prosecutors.
“None of the defendants’ arguments merit the extraordinary remedy of dismissal,” Sorokin wrote, adding “the issues presented by the defendants’ motion are not purely legal ones capable of resolution without a trial on the merits.’’
Sorokin noted that Brissette and Sullivan faced a “heavy burden” to have the case thrown out. Dismissing an indictment, Sorokin wrote, citing case law, “directly encroaches upon the fundamental role of the grand jury.”
Sullivan’s attorney, Thomas R. Kiley, expressed displeasure with the ruling and stood by the arguments for dismissal.
“We’re disappointed,” Kiley said, “but fully committed to defending these completely innocent actions.”
The ruling came on the day Walsh began gathering signatures to secure his name on the ballot for reelection. It means the criminal case will continue to play out as Walsh tries to persuade voters to give him a second term.
Walsh’s chief communications officer, Laura K. Oggeri, declined to comment. Brissette’s attorney, William H. Kettlewell, did not immediately respond for comment.
Brissette, the city’s tourism head, and Sullivan, head of intergovernmental affairs, retain their jobs but are on paid administrative leave. They had argued in court papers they committed no crime when they asked the Boston Calling music festival to pay workers fair wages.
But federal prosecutors argued in the recent filings that Brissette and Sullivan went too far when they used the power of their positions to threaten concert organizers they could lose permits — and $3 million in revenue from the music festival, and the possibility of hosting future concerts — if they failed to hire union workers.
Sorokin’s ruling offered a point-by-point rebuttal of Brissette’s and Sullivan’s argument that the case should be thrown out. The ruling noted, for example, that the defense contended “it is undisputed that neither defendant sought or acquired any money in the course of this alleged extortion.”
The judge stated prosecutors have alleged the extortion was for wages and benefits for union members.
One of the two men killed in an early-morning fire on Hanover Street was a fixture in the North End, while the other was a 33-year-old Hamilton native.Continue reading »
Though coyote attacks around New England are rare, coyotes are not. Here’s how to ward them off.Continue reading »
Everywhere amid the noise and jostle in the terminals this week came happiness as long-separated loved ones reunited.Continue reading »
The new head of the Massachusetts State Police this week made her first appointments, including picking her second-in-command.Continue reading »
Jana Novotna, the Czech tennis star who famously cried on the Duchess of Kent’s shoulder after losing a Wimbledon singles final in 1993 and then triumphed at the same tournament five years later, died Sunday in the Czech Republic. She was 49.Continue reading »
A Newton woman posted a photo of a coyote she spotted to warn her neighbors about the dangers of the wild animals.Continue reading »
The law overturns a 15-year-old ballot measure that supported English-only teaching.Continue reading »
A woman was in the middle of telling officers about a coyote when it suddenly appeared and attacked her.Continue reading »
Dr. John T. Harrington, 80, of West Roxbury, who died Oct. 31, formerly was dean of Tufts University School of Medicine.Continue reading »