Company may make changes to ship after death of man who fell overboard

Globe file
The Provincetown II.

State officials are launching an investigation into whether any alcohol laws were violated after a 21-year-old man fell overboard and died during a party cruise Saturday night.

Meanwhile, the company that owns the ship said it is looking to make physical changes to part of the boat to make it harder for anyone to fall or climb overboard.

Aaron J. Dibella of Peabody fell from the Provincetown II cruise ship during a tropical luau party at about 8:30 p.m. Saturday after climbing the bulwark, the steel barrier along the ship’s edge.


Efforts to rescue him failed. His body was recovered from the water around 1 a.m. Sunday near Peddocks Island at a depth of around 45 feet, according to authorities.

Matthew Almon
Aaron J. Dibella.
Get Metro Headlines in your inbox:
The 10 top local news stories from metro Boston and around New England delivered daily.
Thank you for signing up! Sign up for more newsletters here

The Bay State Cruise Company, which owns the boat, has said Dibella had been “engaging in horseplay” before he fell.

One of the man’s friends on board, Matthew Almon, 21, said Dibella had been drinking, though not to excess. And while Dibella had decided to “joke around” it was an “honest mistake.”

The friend has criticized how staff on board the ship handled the incident, saying he could not find any staff to help for the first crucial minutes after Dibella fell and that the crew did not use other equipment in their rescue efforts.

The state Alcoholic Beverage Control Commission on Monday said it will launch an investigation.


Kris Foster, general counsel for the agency, which licenses businesses to serve alcohol and enforces related regulations, said she could not give details of the investigation or say how long it will take.

But generally investigators “really look for any type of violation of the law,” including patrons being overserved, staff not properly checking IDs, and overcrowding.

She said investigations are initiated in one of two ways: either a complaint is made to the agency or its investigators learn of a situation themselves. She could not say which prompted the investigation into Saturday’s incident.

Foster said in order to serve alcohol on a boat, a “ship master license” must be obtained. The agency conducts inspections and requires safety and security plans before issuing such licenses and it periodically inspects license holders to monitor for compliance, she said.

There are 80 active ship master licenses statewide, she said.


No ship master license holders, including the Bay State Cruise Company, have had violations since at least 2011, Foster said.

The company’s owner, Michael Glasfeld, said in an e-mail the company has not had a liquor violation in more than 15 years “and we are not under the impression that the investigation into this tragic event will result in one either.”

In addition to the alcohol control agency, State Police detectives assigned to the Plymouth County district attorney’s office along with the State Police dive team and its Crime Scene Services Section and the US Coast Guard were investigating, officials said. The state medical examiner’s office was working to determine the exact cause and manner of Dibella’s death.

Glasfeld said he expects the company will be cleared of wrongdoing.

“We do, however, remain open to the inputs of all the agencies we have met with as we value their vast experience and stand to benefit from whatever input they provide,” Glasfeld wrote.

He said the company is exploring making physical changes to the bulwark of the ship.

“While it is already higher than what is required by the Code of Federal Regulations, we believe we can make physical changes to make it even more difficult to scale,” Glasfeld wrote. “This would be akin to what we see when we drive upon bridges where the side rails are protected to prevent people from willingly going over.”

“It’s not something we’ve seen anybody try to climb over before, in decades of carrying people, and has given us enormous pause,” he added.

In 2013, a 41-year-old man died after falling from the third deck of the same boat, which the company also attributed to horseplay. After that incident, the company raised the ship’s handrails — a different area and structure than the bulwark — to roughly a foot above the regulatory requirement, Glasfeld said.

He said the sadness of what happened has been “overwhelming.”

“Our crew are devastated, of course,” Glasfeld said. “While our frequent drilling in man overboard retrieval, well above what is required, provided for the quick response and deploying of the multiple life rings and retrieval gear, the shock of seeing a passenger just a few feet from a life ring, and then not make it, is something we don’t think they’ll ever put out of their mind.”

Globe correspondent Amelia Nierenberg and Jerome Campbell of the Globe staff contributed to this report. Matt Rocheleau can be reached at Follow him on Twitter @mrochele.