scorecardresearch Skip to main content

At Harvard, Harvey Weinstein is now a cause for concern

Harvey Weinstein (left) went into court last month with Winthrop House faculty dean Ronald S. Sullivan Jr. (center).Mark Lennihan/associated press/Associated Press

CAMBRIDGE — To witness all the tumult, you might think Harvey Weinstein had just moved onto Harvard’s campus.

That is not the case.

But the news that the disgraced Hollywood producer has chosen for his legal “dream team” a faculty dean of one of Harvard’s residential houses has unleashed a wave of concern on campus.

Holding signs that said “Harvard Doesn’t Care” and “Down with the Dean,” students protested outside the president’s office in Harvard Yard on Monday, demanding that the administration immediately remove Winthrop House faculty dean Ronald S. Sullivan Jr. from his position.

“It is absolutely morally unacceptable,” said Hilda Jordan, a Harvard senior who was among about 40 students protesting, many wearing tape over their mouths. “Harvard, we want to see you do better. We want to see you hold your administrators, your deans to the same standards that you are attempting to hold your students.”


Sullivan, who teaches at Harvard Law, lives in Winthrop House, one of the dozen residential buildings that house almost all Harvard undergraduates. But since late last month, he’s also one of the criminal defense attorneys representing Weinstein, the Hollywood producer whose name became synonymous with sexual misconduct and professional malpractice in 2017 when legions of film professionals began making their accusations public.

High-profile cases are not new for Sullivan. He helped win an acquittal in the double-murder case against former New England Patriots player Aaron Hernandez in 2017 and he previously represented actress Rose McGowan — one of Weinstein’s fiercest accusers — on a drug possession charge.

Nor is he a stranger to controversy, having represented the family of Michael Brown in a settlement with the city of Ferguson, Mo., over their wrongful death claim. And last year, he represented a Harvard student whose forcible arrest, while he was naked and delusional, raised public concerns of police brutality.


Sullivan was a faculty dean during all those cases, too. But Weinstein, it seems, is another matter.

“This is about someone who is in a pastoral role — who we’re supposed to feel safe and supported with — literally protecting the person who started the #MeToo movement.”said Madeleine Woods, a survivor of sexual assault who lives in Winthrop House. Stephanie Ebbert/Globe Staff

Students and even some faculty have been raising concerns since the Harvard Crimson student newspaper began reporting on the flap at the end of January. And some have questioned the judgment of a faculty dean, who will sometimes hear students’ own accounts of sexual assault, moonlighting as counsel for the most famously offensive accused offender in recent memory.

“Is it good judgment to undertake such a high-profile defense?” Diana Eck, a religious studies professor who serves as faculty dean in another house, said at the protest. She said a reconsideration of faculty deans’ roles may be in order, even though she noted that she believes every defendant, however unpopular, has the right to legal representation.

“That’s extremely important, and law school professors do this all the time,” she added. “But for our part, we also expect there to be choices made in the interests of our students and the community of students that we try to nurture in the house.”

But a Harvard Law graduate taught by Sullivan said the students are mistaking the attorney’s role.

“Do you really think that lawyers are an extension of the criminals they represent?” she asked.

The woman, whose name is being withheld at her request since she is a survivor of sexual assault, said Sullivan advocated for her personally, encouraged her to pursue an assault charge, and offered to handle her case pro bono.

He has done the same for other women at Harvard, she noted, often taking up the case of the accuser rather than the accused. And, she noted, in law school he was known for encouraging students to practice both sides — as prosecutor and defense — often trading the roles himself.


“It’s completely flawed to suggest that attorneys can’t step into and out of roles and representations and keep them separate,” said the woman, who went on to become a sex crimes prosecutor. “Otherwise, we wouldn’t be able to have lives.”

Sullivan declined to speak for this story. In an e-mail he circulated to students, obtained by the Globe, he noted that America’s legal system rests on a presumption of innocence and the right to effective representation.

“It is particularly important for this category of unpopular defendant to receive the same process as everyone else – perhaps even more important,” Sullivan wrote. “To the degree we deny unpopular defendants basic due process rights we cease to be the country we imagine ourselves to be.”

In the e-mail, Sullivan noted that he has secured the release of many people who were wrongfully convicted, some of whom served decades in prison for crimes they did not commit.

“The US criminal process teaches us that the system only works if we defend those whom we perceive as guilty, as vigorously as those whom we perceive to be innocent,” Sullivan wrote.

But some of the students objecting to his role say he is no mere lawyer, but a mentor — and as counsel to Weinstein, they are suddenly questioning his allegiance to them.


“This case is not just about the law. Everyone has a right to a lawyer,” said Madeleine Woods, a survivor of sexual assault who lives in Winthrop House. “But this is about someone who is in a pastoral role — who we’re supposed to feel safe and supported with — literally protecting the person who started the #MeToo movement.”

In a few months, when Weinstein’s case goes to trial, Woods said, her faculty dean might be seen interrogating “women just like me, who for so long have been questioned over and over about the validity of their claims and frankly belittled and pushed away.”

Others bristled at comments Sullivan made regarding Roland Fryer, a Harvard professor who has been accused of sexual harassment, suggesting the case demonstrated what could happen in the current movement, with “some blood in the water, and good coaching [of witnesses].”

Danu Mudannayake, one of the students who organized the protest, asked Harvard to establish accountability and clear standards for faculty dean behavior and demanded that Sullivan “formally apologize for making students and survivors feel ignored in their own homes.”

Harvard dean of the college Rakesh Khurana issued a statement Monday saying that he takes students’ concerns seriously and that he has met with Sullivan “to discuss his responsibilities to the House.” He also said that he “communicated that the College believes that more work must be done to uphold our commitment to the well-being of our students.”


Stephanie Ebbert can be reached at Follow her on Twitter @StephanieEbbert