fb-pixel Skip to main content

Lou Michaels, 80; missed kicks in 1969 Super Bowl

Mr. Michaels was a versatile star for the University of Kentucky in the late 1950s.
Mr. Michaels was a versatile star for the University of Kentucky in the late 1950s.Associated Press/file 1956/Associated Press

NEW YORK — Lou Michaels, a former All-American, all-purpose football player whose two missed field goals for the Baltimore Colts helped the New York Jets win the Super Bowl in 1969 in a historic upset, died Tuesday at his home in Swoyersville, Pa. He was 80.

His son-in-law Mark Grochocki, who confirmed the death, said Mr. Michaels had pancreatic cancer.

Mr. Michaels, who was 6 feet 2 inches and weighed more than 240 pounds, almost never left the field for the University of Kentucky in the late 1950s, playing tackle on offense and many positions on defense as well as kicking and punting.


He was an all-American in 1956 and 1957, the same year he was named Southeastern Conference player of the year. He came in fourth in the voting for the Heisman Trophy.

The Los Angeles Rams picked Mr. Michaels in the first round of the 1958 NFL draft, mainly to play defensive end. In 1961 he moved to the Pittsburgh Steelers and became a regular place-kicker as well as a defensive player.

The next season he kicked 26 field goals (the most in the NFL that year) and scored a career-high total of 110 points. In his 13-year career he kicked 187 field goals, with a success rate of 54.8 percent.

Traded to Baltimore in 1964, Mr. Michaels went on to kick five field goals in a game against the San Francisco 49ers in 1966, tying the league record at the time. After that season he was mainly a kicker.

The 1968 Colts went 15-1 and shut out the Cleveland Browns, 34-0, in the NFL championship on their way to the third Super Bowl, where they faced the Jets, the American Football League upstarts led by the swaggering quarterback Joe Namath.

AFL teams had been dominated in the first two Super Bowls, and the Colts were given 7-1 odds.


Winning was personal for Mr. Michaels — his brother Walt was the Jets’ defensive coordinator. It became even more personal when Mr. Michaels bumped into Namath at a Miami restaurant the weekend before the game.

Namath was drinking Scotch at the bar when Mr. Michaels introduced himself. Namath replied that the Jets would shellac the Colts in the coming game. Recalling the incident, Mr. Michaels told The New York Times in 1983, “If you’re looking for a fight, that’s going to do it.”

There was no fight. Namath actually paid the tab for Mr. Michaels and a teammate, then gave them a ride back to their hotel. A few days later, Namath famously guaranteed a Jets victory.

Baltimore was intercepted four times during the game, once on a flubbed flea-flicker, a trick play, just before halftime, and Mr. Michaels missed field goals from 27 and 46 yards. The Jets won, 16-7.

“I am disgusted with myself,” Mr. Michaels told The Washington Post in 1969. “I started out kicking in seventh grade. I get all the way to the Super Bowl and I goof.”

Baltimore released Mr. Michaels in 1970. The next season the Colts beat the Dallas Cowboys in the fifth Super Bowl, 16-13, winning in the last seconds on a field goal by Jim O’Brien.

Louis Andrew Michaels was born in Swoyersville. He attended Swoyersville High School, where he played football, basketball, and baseball. After his sophomore year he transferred to Staunton Military Academy in Virginia. He graduated in 1954.


He retired from football after spending the 1971 season with the Green Bay Packers, returning to Swoyersville to become a tavern owner and a prison athletic director.

He leaves his wife, the former Judith Mis, whom he married in 1966, as well as two sons, Edward and Matthew; a daughter, Michele Grochocki; five grandchildren; and his brother Walt.

The sting of losing the big game never left him, Mr. Michaels told The Baltimore Sun in 2010. “People say, ‘Forget about it,’ ” he said. “How do you do that when your brother has your Super Bowl ring?”