Next Score View the next score

    N.Y. ‘fracking’ case tests home rule law

    Appeals panel hears challenge by gas industry

    ALBANY, N.Y. — Backers of natural gas drilling and environmental advocates wrangled Thursday over whether New York’s towns have the legal right to ban oil and gas development in a fight that could ultimately be decided by the state’s highest court.

    A four-judge appellate panel heard arguments over the local bans in Dryden and Middlefield, two central New York towns among dozens in the state that have passed zoning laws prohibiting drilling. Opponents say state rules supersede such local restrictions.

    The Dryden law is being challenged by drilling company Norse Energy, and the Middlefield ban by a dairy farmer who said the town’s action prevents her from making money from gas wells that had been planned for her land.


    The cases are being closely watched by other towns across the state as a test of their constitutional right of ‘‘home rule.’’ They’re also of keen interest to the industry, which has said it can’t operate profitably in a state with a patchwork of local regulations that may shift with each town board election.

    Get Ground Game in your inbox:
    Daily updates and analysis on national politics from James Pindell.
    Thank you for signing up! Sign up for more newsletters here

    In the past few years, more than 50 New York municipalities have banned gas drilling, and more than 100 have enacted moratoriums on drilling activities. The bans stem from concerns about potential harm to the environment if the state lifts its five-year moratorium on gas drilling that uses high-volume hydraulic fracturing, or fracking. The process frees gas from deep rock deposits by injecting wells with chemical-laced water at high pressure.

    Trial-level state Supreme Court judges have already upheld bans in Dryden, Middlefield, and the Livingston County town of Avon.

    At the heart of the cases is the interpretation of a state law passed in 1981 that says regulation of the oil and gas industry rests solely with the state Department of Environmental Conservation, which ‘‘supersedes’’ local ordinances.

    ‘‘Our argument is that the towns of Dryden and Middlefield are not trying to regulate the industry; they recognize that regulating the industry is a matter for the state,’’ said Deborah Goldberg, a lawyer with an environmental group, Earth­justice, who is representing Dryden. “The town of Dryden is exercising its constitutionally protected local power to regulate land use through zoning.’’


    Tom West, representing Norse, said the oil and gas law seeks to prevent waste of the resource and protect the mineral rights of multiple landowners.

    The panel is expected to take six to eight weeks to rule.