Atlanta archbishop apologizes for posh $2.2m home

Cleric yields to critics, pope’s message

ATLANTA — Archbishop Wilton Gregory seems to have gotten the pope’s message about modest living.

Days after Pope Francis permanently removed a German bishop for his lavish spending on a new residence, the Atlanta archbishop apologized for building a $2.2 million mansion as his residence. He bowed to criticism from local parishioners and said he would consider selling the new home in Buckhead, Atlanta’s toniest neighborhood.

In letters, e-mails, and a meeting, local Catholics told Gregory the price tag was outlandish, especially in light of Francis’ frugality. The Tudor-style mansion, stretching nearly 6,400 square feet, includes two dining rooms and a safe room. The archbishop said the new pope has ‘‘set the bar’’ for church leaders and others, and Gregory said he hadn’t looked at the project’s cost in terms of his own ‘‘integrity and pastoral credibility.’’


‘‘I failed to consider the impact on the families throughout the archdiocese who, though struggling to pay their mortgages, utilities, tuition, and other bills, faithfully respond year after year to my pleas to assist with funding our ministries and services,’’ Gregory wrote late Monday on the website of the archdiocesan newspaper.

Get Ground Game in your inbox:
Daily updates and analysis on national politics from James Pindell.
Thank you for signing up! Sign up for more newsletters here

It’s a challenge bishops will be facing more pointedly — and publicly — in the age of Francis.

In the Archdiocese of Newark, parishioners have criticized Archbishop John Myers, and withheld some donations, after they learned the archdiocese was spending at least $500,000 to expand his retirement home, adding an indoor therapy pool, fireplaces, and an office library. Last week, Francis removed German bishop Franz-Peter Tebartz-van Elst after he spent $43 million on a new residence and related renovations.

‘‘More people are thinking about it, how to tone it down as far as their living arrangements,’’ said Russell Shaw, a former spokesman for the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops and a Catholic writer.

The Vatican declined to comment Tuesday.


Pope Francis has made clear he expects his priests and bishops to follow his example of humility, imploring them to refrain from driving fancy cars or using the latest iPhone. To emphasize the point, Francis convened the heads of all Vatican offices Tuesday to discuss implementing his apostolic exhortation ‘‘The Joy of the Gospel.’’

In the statement, Francis denounces the ‘‘idolatry of money,’’ self-indulgence, and ‘‘insidious worldliness’’ within the church, and laments how the poor have been excluded from the global economy.

Gregory’s new residence was made possible by a $15 million gift from the nephew of Margaret Mitchell, the author of the Civil War epic ‘‘Gone With The Wind.’’ When Joseph Mitchell died in 2011, he left much of his estate to the archdiocese, asking that the proceeds be used for ‘‘general religious and charitable purposes.’’ Mitchell sought primary consideration for his home parish, Christ the King Cathedral.

The archdiocese set aside $7.5 million for the cathedral’s building fund. Another $3.75 million went to Catholic Charities and other service groups, and several million more went to disadvantaged parishes, parish endowments, a retirement fund for priests, and a Jesuit high school.

But Gregory needed a new home after giving up his residence near the cathedral, where more space was needed for a growing congregation.


Gregory initially defended the decision as an accommodation he had made for the sake of the cathedral. But parishioners raised questions, and some met with him to directly voice their concern about the expenditure.