fb-pixel Skip to main content

Studies highlight teacher-student ‘diversity gap’

Groups call for racially varied instructor corps

WASHINGTON — US teachers are nowhere near as diverse as their students: Almost half the students attending public schools are minorities, yet fewer than 1 in 5 of their teachers is not white, according to two new studies.

The studies from the Center for American Progress and the National Education Association are calling attention to this ‘‘diversity gap’’ at elementary and secondary schools in the United States. The groups want more to be done to help teachers more accurately mirror the students in their classrooms.

Teachers are always pushing their students to excel, said Kevin Gilbert, coordinator of teacher leadership and special projects for the Clinton Public School District in Clinton, Miss. It becomes easier for students to believe ‘‘when they can look and see someone who looks just like them, that they can relate to,’’ said Gilbert, a member of the education association’s executive committee. ‘‘Nothing can help motivate our students more than to see success standing right in front of them.’’

More than minority students would benefit from a more diverse teacher corps, said Ulrich Boser, the author of the center’s report.


‘‘Even in a place like North Dakota, where the students aren’t particularly diverse relative to the rest of the country, it’s important for our social fabric, for our sense as a nation, that students are engaging with people who think, talk, and act differently than them but can also be just as effective at raising student achievement in the classroom,’’ he said.

There were about 3.3 million teachers in American public elementary and secondary schools in 2012, according to a study by the National Center for Education Statistics. It said 82 percent were white, 8 percent were Hispanic, 7 percent were black, and about 2 percent were Asian.

Students are a different story. In 1993, minority-race students made up 31 percent of the public school population; it was 41 percent in 2003.


Recent statistics from the Center for American Progress show that 48 percent of the students in public schools are not white and that percentage is expected to continue to increase. The center’s study said that almost every state has a significant diversity gap.

In California, 73 percent of students are not white, but only about 29 percent of teachers are not white. Maryland has the same problem, though the numbers are a bit better: In the Old Line State, more than 55 percent of students are not white, while about 17 percent of teachers are not white.

In Massachusetts, there are large gaps between black students and black teachers in the Boston public schools, according to the Center for American Progress study. The city’s percentage of black teachers has fallen to 21 percent, it said.

Chelsea public schools have a 76 percentage-point gap between the percentages of Hispanic teachers and students, the study found. In the Randolph public schools, 52 percent of students are black, but less than 5 percent of the district’s teachers are black.

Overall, public schools in the nation have a diversity index of 30, which represents the percentage-point difference between teachers and students who are not white, according to the center’s study, which examined data from the 2010-11 school year. The diversity index was 29 for Massachusetts, the study said.

Many states have programs aimed at increasing teacher diversity, but both groups said the efforts are not keeping up with the increase in minority populations.


‘‘We project that this fall, for the first time in American history, the majority of public school students in America will be nonwhite,’’ Education Secretary Arne Duncan said last week.

Hispanics have passed blacks as the largest minority group of teachers, just as there are more Hispanic students than blacks in the public school system. This tracks with the increases in the number of Hispanics in the United States, with Latinos the largest minority group in the country and the fastest growing.

Jan Alderson, a science teacher at Shawnee Mission South High School in Overland Park, Kan., saw the changes at her school.

‘‘We have very few teachers of minority background yet we’ve gone to about 40 percent minority population,’’ said Alderson, who was inducted into the National Teacher Hall of Fame this past week. ‘‘It’s a beautiful blending, it’s just teachers who don’t have that cultural background, I think just that there are more issues.’’

Teaching used be one of the few professions that black college graduates could aspire to and make decent money, said LaRuth Gray, who is scholar in residence at the Metropolitan Center for Research on Equity and the Transformation of Schools at New York University.

But as the county integrated and other professions opened their ranks, education lost its cachet and fewer black students thought about becoming teachers, she said.

‘‘It’s not seen as the ideal careers to have, and so therefore our youngsters, our black children tend to move in other directions,’’ said Gray, who also serves as a government liaison for the National Alliance of Black School Educators.