In Trump’s plan, an unsettling echo from US past

Up to million Mexicans were ousted in 1930s

Hundreds of Mexicans packed a Los Angeles train station to await deportation to Mexico in 1932. They were part of a forced repatriation.
Los Angeles Herald Examiner Collection/Los Angeles Public Library via AP
Hundreds of Mexicans packed a Los Angeles train station to await deportation to Mexico in 1932. They were part of a forced repatriation.

ALBUQUERQUE — Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump’s call for mass deportation of millions of immigrants living in the United States illegally, as well as their American-born children, bears similarities to a large-scale removal that many Mexican-American families faced 85 years ago.

During the Great Depression, counties and cities in the American Southwest and Midwest forced Mexican immigrants and their families to leave over concerns they were taking jobs away from whites despite their legal right to stay.

The result: Around 500,000 to 1 million Mexican immigrants and Mexican Americans were pushed out of the country during the 1930s repatriation, as the removal is sometimes called.


Immigrants were rounded up, sometimes in public places and often without formal proceedings. Others, scared under the threat of violence, left voluntarily.

Get Ground Game in your inbox:
Daily updates and analysis on national politics from James Pindell.
Thank you for signing up! Sign up for more newsletters here

About 60 percent of those who left were US citizens, according to various studies. Later testimonies show families lost most of their possessions and some family members died trying to return. Neighborhoods in cities such as Houston, San Antonio, and Los Angeles became empty.

The impact of the experience on Latinos remains evident today, experts and advocates say.

‘‘It set the tone for later deportations,’’ said Francisco Balderrama, a Chicano studies professor at California State University Los Angeles.

Two weeks ago, Trump said that, if elected president, he would expand deportations and end ‘‘birthright citizenship’’ for children born to immigrants who are here illegally. Under his plan, American-born children of immigrants would be deported with their parents, and Mexico would be asked to help build a wall along the US border.


‘‘They’re illegal,’’ Trump said of US-born children of people in the country illegally. ‘‘You either have a country or not.’’

Trump has provided few details on how his proposed deportation effort would be carried out. The conservative-leaning American Action Forum concluded in a report it would cost between $400 billion to $600 billion and take 20 years to remove an estimated 11.2 million immigrants living in the country illegally.

The large-scale deportation he envisions would be impractical to enact, due to the extent to which Mexican immigrants have integrated into US society, said Columbia University history professor Mae Ngai.

US-born children of immigrants have been automatically considered American citizens since the adoption of the Constitution’s 14th Amendment in 1868.

A Supreme Court ruling in 1898 halted previous attempts to limit the birthright of Chinese-American citizens.


The ruling upheld the clause for all US-born children, Ngai said, and there have been no successful challenges to the clause since.

In the 1930s, Balderrama said, officials skirted the issue of birthright citizenship by saying they did not want to break up families.

‘‘But they did break up families and many children never saw their parents again,’’ said Balderrama, co-author of a book about the repatriation in the 1930s with the late historian Raymond Rodriguez, who testified at a California committee about seeing his father for the last time at age 10, before the father left for Mexico.

That legacy lingers in songs, often played on Spanish-language radio stations, that allude to mass deportations and separation of loved ones, said Lilia Soto, an American studies professor at the University of Wyoming.

For example, the lyrics to ‘‘Ice El Hielo,’’ by the Los Angeles band La Santa Cecilia, speak of a community afraid that federal agents are/ about to arrive and launch deportation raids at any moment.

The ballad ‘‘Volver, Volver,’’ sung by Mexican Vicente Fernandez, speaks of someone vowing to return to a lover despite all obstacles.