Sanders campaign shifting to broaden primary appeal
MANCHESTER, N.H. — About a third of the seats were empty when Vermont Senator Bernie Sanders stopped to give a lunchtime talk to seniors here during a swing through the state.
The firebrand presidential candidate didn’t even command the full attention of the room — one group remained seated at a table playing a game of cards as Sanders thundered on about saving Social Security and reducing the price of prescription drugs.
Other events on a two-day swing drew greater interest, but for a campaign known to attract thousands, the crowd Friday was one of his smallest and was perhaps a metaphor for the next act of Sanders’ campaign. It’s shaping up to be more combative and negative, with direct barbs pointing at front-runner Hillary Clinton. It will be more targeted, with messages tailored specifically to key voting groups still inclined to be skeptical of Sanders’ message.
As the Democratic contest has become essentially a two-way race heading into the final three months before voting begins, Sanders is trying to move beyond his core audience while also keeping his base revved up.
Though national polls show the odds are against him, and his senior staff acknowledges that Clinton is finding her footing, the Sanders campaign is readying for combat. They’ve pledged to double down in Iowa and New Hampshire, where Sanders held three town hall meetings and planned to go trick-or-treating with his three grandchildren who live in the state on Saturday evening.
Soon, perhaps as early as next week, pro-Sanders TV commercials will begin. Despite the candidate’s philosophical aversion to poll-tested messages, these spots were guided by polling data that his campaign has only recently started collecting and analyzing.
The Sanders commercials weren’t finalized by last week — but outlines hit on Sanders biography and seemed tailored to address a weakness: That Sanders’ iconoclastic outsider message doesn’t convey to some that he has the skills and temperament to govern.
“We need to introduce Bernie Sanders to people,” said Tad Devine, a senior adviser to the campaign who spent last Wednesday in an editing room cutting ads. “Bernie’s political identity was forged winning electoral contests outside the normal bounds of an election.”
The ads allow Sanders to deploy another weapon: the $25 million pile of cash sitting in his campaign bank account. That funding could allow Sanders to match Clinton’s campaign spending on television, which began in early August.
Expanding his reach beyond the Sanders faithful can be humbling — as evidenced on Friday at the William B. Cashin Senior Activity Center in Manchester. Recent public polls show Sanders ahead in New Hampshire, but among seniors, Clinton holds a commanding lead. A Sanders campaign aide explained that the event was organized by the senior center, and the campaign didn’t advertise it.
Sanders adjusted to the size of the crowd — asking audience members questions to engage them in more of a conversation as he gave his speech. “You’ll ask me questions, I’ll ask you questions,” Sanders said at the top.
His question, though, felt a bit rhetorical. “Tell me how, in a climate like New Hampshire or Vermont where it gets pretty cold in the winter, people have to pay heat bills, how does a senior citizen, often dealing with health problems — you’re 80 or 85 years old — how do you survive on $13,000 or $14,000 a year?”
He did get an actual response: An audience member suggested food banks and charity.
As he was ushered out, Sanders also made an effort to engage the card players — stopping by for a quick hello before rushing out of the center.
In Virginia on Wednesday, he catered to a different audience: youth. He used what he called a “national town hall” with students at George Mason University (and more than 250 other colleges listening on line) to talk about legalizing marijuana, which Sanders supports.
But the larger shift in recent days is Sanders’ eagerness to take on Clinton more directly in national news appearances and even at times on the campaign trail. There’s risk in this tack, as it could turn off the voters who see him as a different kind of politician. Joe Trippi, who managed Howard Dean’s 2004 insurgent bid for the Democratic nomination, warned that Sanders’ “new ‘get tough’ strategy is hurting the brand.”
In New Hampshire amid brilliant fall foliage Friday, Sanders referenced Clinton by name repeatedly while talking to seniors and again during a visit to his Nashua campaign office.
But he only alluded to Clinton during a Friday evening town hall in Derry that attracted more than 400 people — saying that those in the audience “may have seen one or more of her ads.”
Several of those who attended said they don’t want personal attacks. “I appreciate the way he is campaigning so far,” said Kathy Thomson, 62, who attended the meeting.
However, the brewing showdown was also evident in a round of televised interviews and speeches last week, in which Sanders drew sharper contrasts between his views and Clinton’s — particularly on the subject of regulating Wall Street.
“If people are satisfied with the establishment politics, you’ve got a candidate,” Sanders said during an hourlong interview with Charlie Rose last week. “If you want real change, I’m the candidate.”
Sanders also became mired in the sort of daily back-and-forth with the Clinton camp that he has said he seeks to avoid. The tiff started after Clinton, who for months hardly ever acknowledged Sanders, seized on a comment he made during the Democratic debate last month that there’s too much “shouting” about changing gun laws. During an event in Virginia shortly after the Democratic debate, Clinton said: “When a woman speaks out, some people think it’s shouting.” She repeated the refrain at several other events.
Clinton declined to answer questions at a campaign stop in New Hampshire on Thursday about whether she considers his words “sexist.” But her campaign has kept up the sexism drumbeat, via surrogates.
On Saturday, Sanders acknowledged at a press conference that the campaign has become more personal. “I think that is unfortunate,” he said.