scorecardresearch Skip to main content

Potential for new border crisis prompted immigrant raids

“Having people afraid to open their doors to strangers, not going to work, etc., is not a healthy development,” Representative Zoe Lofgren, a California Democrat, said Tuesday.Jacquelyn Martin/Associated Press

WASHINGTON — A spike in families and children arriving at the US southern border from Central America has prompted fears of another crisis like the one that dominated national news during the summer of 2014. That could roil an already tumultuous presidential race, giving more momentum to Republican front-runner Donald Trump while creating problems for Democratic candidate Hillary Clinton and President Obama.

The number of Central American families and unaccompanied minors arriving at the border this fall more than doubled from the year before, according to the most recent figures. The numbers could go even higher beginning in February and early spring, when arrivals traditionally increase, potentially eclipsing the levels that produced the 2014 crisis.


Such concerns helped prompt the Department of Homeland Security, with the close involvement of the White House, to initiate crackdowns on migrants in several states over the holidays, picking up 121 people for deportation. In some instances, people were detained during surprise early morning home raids that have infuriated the president’s Democratic allies.

Clinton broke with Obama on the issue at an Iowa forum Monday night, calling for an end to the raids that she said “have sown fear and division in immigrant communities across the country.”

“We have laws and we must be guided by those laws, but we shouldn’t have armed federal officers showing up at people’s homes, taking women and children out of their beds in the middle of the night,” she said in a statement.

On Capitol Hill, House Democrats were releasing a letter signed by more than 100 lawmakers demanding an end to the raids.

“Having people afraid to open their doors to strangers, not going to work, etc., is not a healthy development,” said Representative Zoe Lofgren, a California Democrat.

Lofgren said she shares concerns about a renewed Central American border crisis, but like other Democrats argued that the migrants should be treated as refugees. Many are fleeing brutal gang warfare in El Salvador, Honduras, and Guatemala, the same countries whose violence and instability forced women and kids to make the dangerous trip north two years ago, overwhelming US facilities and producing disturbing images of frightened children huddling in Border Patrol facilities.


Such images remain vivid to policymakers, and avoiding a repeat is a priority. This time it would come in the middle of a presidential campaign where immigration is already a fraught topic, with Trump insisting he would deport everyone here illegally while senators Ted Cruz of Texas and Marco Rubio of Florida exchange barbs about who has the stronger record on this issue.

A new border crisis could only incite such disputes, while putting the White House on the defensive.

Administration officials say they are better prepared than they were in 2014 for a new influx, including increased capacity to house children. But the administration has limited strategies to stem the tide. It has stepped up advertising in Central American countries to warn of the dangers of the trip and point to $750 million in a year-end spending bill to help those nations.

And officials defend the controversial raids, which have been denounced by the other Democratic presidential candidates in addition to Clinton while drawing praise from Trump, who also took credit for them. Although Democrats question whether such crackdowns will deter desperate women and children, White House officials said the tactics are in line with new deportation policies outlined by the Obama administration that prioritize criminals and recent arrivals. All those targeted had arrived after 2014 and had exhausted their legal options.


“Our desire to make clear that individuals should not embark on the dangerous journey from Central America to the Southwest border, that’s a case that we’ve tried to tell in a variety of ways,” White House Press Secretary Josh Earnest said.

“It was only after individuals had exhausted the legal remedies available to them . . . was a decision made to remove them,” he said.

Such explanations fall flat for advocates such as Adelina Nicholls, executive director of the Georgia Latino Alliance for Human Rights.

Several of the detention raids were conducted in Georgia, and stories are circulating about immigration officials banging on doors and rounding up families.

“People are very confused; they don’t know what’s going on,” Nicholls said. “We are not happy with Obama.”

Obama himself had pleased many Latinos by issuing executive actions in 2014 sparing millions from deportation, though that plan is now being challenged in court. It was a turnaround after he was labeled “deporter-in-chief” earlier in his administration for presiding over record removals, seen as an effort, ultimately unsuccessful, to win over Republicans to enact comprehensive immigration legislation.