fb-pixelAttack on Bush legacy a risky strategy in S.C. - The Boston Globe Skip to main content

Attack on Bush legacy a risky strategy in S.C.

<?EM-dummyText [Drophead goes here] ?>

Donald Trump and Jeb Bush (seen after the GOP debate Saturday) fought vigorously over the presidency of Jeb’s brother George, who remains very popular in South Carolina.EPA

GREENVILLE, S.C. — George W. Bush won a bruising South Carolina presidential primary on his way to the Oval Office, as did his father before him.

Now it's his brother's turn, and for Jeb Bush, the most consequential foreign policy decisions of his brother's time in office are suddenly front-and-center of his bid to keep alive his campaign for the Republican presidential nomination, thanks to Donald Trump.

The former president had already announced plans to campaign for his younger brother on Monday in South Carolina, marking his most direct entry into the 2016 race to date.

But on Saturday, Trump used the final Republican debate before the state's Feb. 20 primary as an opportunity to excoriate George W. Bush's performance as commander-in-chief.


The former president, Trump said, ignored ''the advice of his CIA'' and ''destabilized the Middle East'' by invading Iraq on dubious claims that Saddam Hussein had weapons of mass destruction.

''I want to tell you: They lied,'' Trump said. ''They said there were weapons of mass destruction; there were none. And they knew there were none.''

Trump didn't let up as Bush tried to defend his brother, dismissing his suggestion that George W. Bush built a ''security apparatus to keep us safe'' after the 9/11 attacks.

''The World Trade Center came down during your brother's reign, remember that,'' Trump said, adding: ''That's not keeping us safe.''

The onslaught, which Jeb Bush called Trump enjoying ''blood sport,'' was the latest example of the billionaire businessman's penchant for mocking his rival as a weak, privileged tool of the Republican Party establishment, special interests, and well-heeled donors.

But the exchange also highlighted the former Florida governor's embrace of his family name and history as he jockeys with Senator Marco Rubio of Florida and Governor John Kasich of Ohio to emerge from South Carolina as the clear challenger to Trump, who won the New Hampshire primary, and Senator Ted Cruz of Texas, the victor in Iowa's caucuses.


The approach tacks away from Bush's months-long insistence that he is running as ''my own man,'' but could be a perfect fit for South Carolina. Senator Lindsey Graham of South Carolina, who ended his GOP presidential campaign in December and endorsed Jeb Bush in January, said: ''The Bush name is golden in my state.''

George W. Bush retains wide appeal among Republicans, from evangelicals to chamber of commerce business leaders and retired members of the military. All are prominent in South Carolina, with Bush campaign aide Brett Foster going so far as to say that George W. Bush is ''the most popular Republican alive.''

After the debate, some Republicans again suggested Trump had gone too far. Bush wasn't alone on stage leaping to his brother's defense, with Rubio coming back to the moment to say, ''I thank God all the time it was George W. Bush in the White House on 9/11 and not Al Gore.''

The attack on George W. Bush carries risk for Trump, given the Bush family's long social and political ties in South Carolina and the state's hawkish national security bent, bolstered by more than a half-dozen military installations and a sizable population of veterans who choose to retire in the state.

Trump has repeatedly defied predictions that his comments might threaten his perch atop the field. And as he jousted Saturday with Trump, Jeb Bush said, ''this is not about my family or his family.''


But the Bush family does have a history in the state that is hard to overlook. In 2000, George W. Bush beat John McCain in a nasty contest, marred by rumors that McCain had an illegitimate black child. McCain adopted a child from Bangladesh. Exit polls showed George W. Bush won nearly every demographic group.

George H.W. Bush, the 41st president, won twice here, beating Bob Dole in 1988 and demolishing Pat Buchanan in 1992.

One of the elder Bush's top strategists, Lee Atwater, hailed from South Carolina and remains a legend in GOP campaign annals. Last week, Jeb Bush touted the endorsement of Iris Campbell, the widow of Carroll Campbell, a former South Carolina governor and a national co-chairman of previous Bush presidential campaigns.

Yet even as he defended his brother's presidency at Saturday's debate, Jeb Bush found a way to distance himself from George W. Bush's business affairs and to criticize Trump at the same time. The issue: eminent domain.

Before entering politics, George W. Bush was part-owner of the Texas Rangers, and their home city of Arlington, Texas, used eminent domain to take private land and build a stadium for the team. Trump has defended such uses of eminent domain as a way to foster economic development.

Retorted Bush, who argued eminent domain should be reserved for public infrastructure projects, ''There is all sorts of intrigue about where I disagree with my brother. There would be one right there.''


In a separate development, Mike Murdock, a prominent Texas-based televangelist, will formally endorse Trump for president at a rally in Greenville on Monday.

"He has a warrior spirit for restoring America in the eyes of the world and he has a warrior's heart," said Murdock, the head pastor at the Wisdom Center ministry, told Bloomberg News in an interview. "I am endorsing him for president."

Murdock, who frequently preaches about prosperity, arguing that a strong moral faith will lead to financial success for Christians, joins a handful of high-profile evangelists who have backed Trump. Two-thirds of Republican voters in the state describe themselves as evangelical.