Politics
    Next Score View the next score

    As Trump muses about seizing Iraq oil, energy experts say it makes no sense

    Workers looked over the Zubair oil field in southern Iraq in 2010.
    ESSAM -AL-SUDANI/AFP/Getty Images
    Workers looked over the Zubair oil field in southern Iraq in 2010.

    WASHINGTON -- Overshadowed by Donald Trump’s false assertions in his first days in office about inauguration crowd size, a highly controversial statement from the new president with greater importance received far less attention.

    Before a group of CIA employees on Saturday, Trump said the United States should have taken Iraq’s oil during its eight-year war there.

    “Now, I said it for economic reasons,” Trump said. “But if you think about it ... if we kept the oil, you probably wouldn’t have ISIS because that’s where they made their money in the first place, so we should have kept the oil. But, OK, maybe we’ll have another chance.”

    Advertisement

    Trump made similar statements during his winning presidential campiagn, including at a forum moderated by NBC’s Matt Lauer on September 7. Now that Trump occupies the Oval Office, his hint that the United States may have another opportunity to seize Iraq’s oil supply is raising fresh objections.

    Get Today in Politics in your inbox:
    A digest of the top political stories from the Globe, sent to your inbox Monday-Friday.
    Thank you for signing up! Sign up for more newsletters here

    “This is foolish,” Kenneth Pollack, a senior fellow at Brookings Institution, said. “This is a typical Trump remark. It’s moronic. It makes no sense. We couldn’t just suddenly grab Iraq’s oil and walk away with it.”

    In order to extract the oil, American forces would need to occupy the country, a costly, dangerous, and politically risky process, Pollack said. He added Iraqi resistance to these efforts would be quite strong given oil is a crucial source of income for the country.

    In response to Trump’s comments, Massachusetts Representative Seth Moulton, a former Marine, tweeted on Saturday, “No. That’s pillaging, and it’s a war crime.” Moulton could not be reached for comment Tuesday.

    Iraqi Prime Minister Haider al-Abadi said Tuesday that Iraq’s oil is the country’s constitutional property, adding that he was still unclear exactly what Trump meant by his comments, according to Reuters.

    Advertisement

    On Monday, when asked to clarify the president’s comments, White House press secretary Sean Spicer said Trump wants to make sure American interests are protected as part of the country’s foreign policy strategy.

    “If we’re going in to a country for a cause, I think that he wants to make sure that America’s getting something out of it for the commitment and the sacrifice that we’re making,” he said.

    At the forum in September, however, Trump made a similar suggestion about taking Iraq’s oil, saying the U.S. would only need to leave “a certain group behind” to do it.

    “It used to be, ‘To the victor belong the spoils,” he said at the time. “Now, there was no victor there, believe me. There was no victor. But I always said: Take the oil.”

    Experts say the process of extracting and transporting oil is time-consuming and expensive.

    Advertisement

    “You can’t take oil any faster than you can pump it out of the earth and to do that, you not only have to secure the well. You have to secure the entire export system,” said Anthony Cordesman, the Burke Chair in Strategy Emeritus at the Center for Strategic and International Studies. “It’s not something that is going to happen particularly peacefully.”

    He added that there would be strategic concerns, given the illegal nature of the proposal.

    “You also have to consider what the reaction would be of virtually every country allied with the United States,” Cordesman said. “It is simply a totally unworkable proposition.”

    Experts also raised questions about the usefulness in seizing Iraq’s oil as a strategy for weakening ISIS. Most of Iraq’s oil is in the south of the country and controlled by Shia Muslims, who hate ISIS, a terrorist organization comprised of Sunni Muslims, said Robert McNally, the president of the Rapidan Group, an energy consulting firm in Bethesda, MD.

    “Nearly all the oil in Iraq is in areas where ISIS doesn’t exist,” he said.

    Tyler Pager can be reached at tyler.pager@globe.com. Follow him on Twitter @tylerpager.