fb-pixelWarren defends heritage claims - The Boston Globe Skip to main content

Warren defends heritage claims

Decries Trump’s attacks in speech to Native Americans

Senator Elizabeth Warren. Erin Schaff/New York Times

WASHINGTON — Senator Elizabeth Warren made a surprise appearance at the National Congress of American Indians Wednesday, forcefully denouncing President Trump’s use of the name “Pocahontas” to deride her and defending her claims of Native American heritage more expansively than she has before.

The Massachusetts Democrat also made an impassioned pledge to advocate for issues of importance for Native Americans. The speech was a clear attempt to put to rest a sensitive issue that has been used by her enemies to attack her character and another signal of her potential 2020 presidential ambitions.

Warren did not apologize for her undocumented claims that her mother’s family had Cherokee blood — instead, reaffirming: “My mother’s family was part Native American. And my daddy’s parents were bitterly opposed to their relationship. So, in 1932, when Mother was 19 and Daddy had just turned 20, they eloped.”


“The story they lived will always be a part of me,” she said, as tears came to her eyes. “And no one — not even the president of the United States — will ever take that part of me away.”

But she told the gathered tribal leaders from around the country that she drew a distinction between claiming native ancestry and claiming tribal membership. She repeatedly referred to Trump’s insensitivity, not only in calling her Pocahontas but in doing it last year during an event at the White House meant to honor Navajo code-talker veterans of World War II.

“The joke, I guess, is supposed to be on me,” she said. “I get why some people think there’s hay to be made here. You won’t find my family members on any rolls, and I’m not enrolled in a tribe. And I want to make something clear. I respect that distinction. I understand that tribal membership is determined by tribes — and only by tribes.”


Responding to critics who claim she used a minority status to gain prestigious law professorships, she said: “I never used my family tree to get a break or get ahead. I never used it to advance my career.”

Warren — who has been criticized for not advocating more aggressively in the Senate for Native American issues, given her claims to ancestry — also appeared to assert greater common cause with Native Americans than she has in the past.

“For far too long, your story has been pushed aside, to be trotted out only in cartoons and commercials,” she said. “So I’m here today to make a promise: Every time someone brings up my family’s story, I’m going to use it to lift up the story of your families and your communities.”

Warren delivered her remarks amid concern from some Democrats that the murkiness surrounding her claims of Native American ancestry could hamper a presidential bid.

Ron Klain, a former top official in the Clinton campaign who also worked for Obama, said he thought Warren’s speech would “take this issue off the table” for liberals and even independents.

“It’s not going to make Donald Trump go away — Donald Trump never goes away,” he said. “But I think she’s done good work on this today.”

While her unverified claims have long been a rallying cry for the right, some liberal outlets have recently begun chiming in, including “The Daily Show” host Trevor Noah and the website ThinkProgress, which hosted a column by a Cherokee activist who called on Warren to apologize. The Globe last month wrote an in-depth story exploring concern among Warren’s own allies.


Rebecca Nagle, the Cherokee activist who wrote the ThinkProgress column, said on Wednesday that the speech was a “giant step in the right direction.”

“It’s a historic moment for Indian country for a senator to make a speech like that,” Nagle said. “That’s exactly what she needed to do.”

Nagle said that she still thinks Warren should further investigate her family’s claims of Cherokee identity.

“I believe her that that’s what her family told her; I just don’t think what her family told her is true,” Nagle said.

Warren’s move to more publicly address the issue had some similarities to former president Barack Obama’s 2008 campaign speeches about race and to Mitt Romney’s 2007 speech about his Mormon faith.

Her speech doesn’t come without significant risks in a toxic political environment and could provide Trump with another opportunity to criticize her. It was also a challenge to her many critics, who have pointed to her claims of Native American heritage as a sign that she can’t be trusted.

Warren has often been reluctant to tackle the touchy issue, but she spoke with force and emotion on Wednesday.

“I’ve noticed that every time my name comes up, President Trump likes to talk about Pocahontas,” Warren began. “So I figured, let’s talk about Pocahontas. Not Pocahontas, the fictional character most Americans know from the movies, but Pocahontas, the Native woman who really lived.”


She contrasted the popular fable — of a woman who met colonist John Smith, fell in love, and became a positive tale of colonization — with a darker, more accurate story of abduction and imprisonment.

“Indigenous people have been telling the story of Pocahontas — the real Pocahontas — for four centuries. A story of heroism. And bravery. And pain,” Warren said. “And, for almost as long, her story has been taken away by powerful people who twisted it to serve their own purposes.”

Warren gave no advance public notice about her appearance before the gathering, which was held at the Capital Hilton in downtown Washington.

While her speech was planned in advance, Warren was not listed on the agenda. The Republican National Committee on Tuesday morning even blasted out an e-mail with the subject: “Fauxcahontas MIA From Major Native American Summit.”

“Maybe it’s because she would face some difficult questions at the summit,” the RNC said.

But instead she was well received inside the banquet hall, receiving standing ovations before and after her speech. “We’ve got your back!” shouted Jefferson Keel, the congress president.

“It’s great to see her come to Indian country and tell her story,” said Rion Ramirez, who is chairman of the Democratic National Committee’s Native American Caucus and a member of the Turtle Mountain Band of Chippewa Indians in Belcourt, N.D. “It’s been long overdue.”

“It’s like anything: The longer you wait on it, the harder it becomes,” he added. “She would probably say she should have done it sooner. You can’t let other people define you.”


Several tribal members said they teared up during portions of her speech. Others said they were not bothered by her claims of heritage, and pointed to their own overlapping tribal identities as proof that such questions are complicated.

“Who are we to say what she is?” said Ricardo Ortiz, a member of the Pueblo of San Felipe tribe in New Mexico. “If she knows what’s in her blood, and believes it, who are we to criticize?”

Trump hadn’t responded to Warren’s speech by late Wednesday afternoon.

Warren grew up in Oklahoma, and was told from an early age that her mother’s side of the family had Native American ancestry. She embraced that heritage during various points in her life, contributing five recipes to a 1984 book called “Pow Wow Chow: A Collection of Recipes From Families of the Five Civilized Tribes: Cherokee, Chickasaw, Choctaw, Creek, and Seminole.”

From 1986 to 1995, she also listed herself as a minority in a legal directory published by the Association of American Law Schools, and she was listed as a Native American in federal forms filed by law schools at Harvard University and the University of Pennsylvania when she was employed at the schools.

Her claims of heritage were first subjected to public scrutiny during her 2012 Senate campaign in Massachusetts. Warren’s rival, Scott Brown, said she not only lied about her roots but used it to advance her career at prestigious law schools.

Those involved in the hiring process have said they did not know about her heritage when hiring her.

Her contacts with the Native American community have been fairly low profile since her election. She’s backed a proposal to allow post offices to offer some financial services, which helps rural communities and could be beneficial to tribes, for example. She’s also worked to ensure data is collected to monitor education in Native American schools, and to combat opioid abuse.

But Wednesday she said she was committed to helping them, and she said she would honor the stories of pride, resilience, and hope.

“But there’s another story that also needs to be told. The story of our country’s mistreatment of your communities,” she said. “And this isn’t just a story about casual racism — war whoops and Tomahawk chops and insulting Facebook memes.”

For too long, she said, elected officials have ignored their plight. And she said she would be paying more attention. This week, according to one of her advisers, she is meeting with a half dozen tribal leaders.

“This must stop,” she added. “And I promise I will fight to help write a different story.”

Matt Viser can be reached at matt.viser@globe.com.