Almost to a man, the bishops who worked under Cardinal Bernard F. Law played strong supporting roles as the archdiocese moved to quell complaints of sexual abuse by moving accused priests from parish to parish.
But the thousands of pages of church records released in clergy abuse lawsuits over the last year show that one bishop complained repeatedly about giving new assignments to problem priests - and was repeatedly ignored.
The warnings issued by John M. D’Arcy, now the bishop of the Fort Wayne-South Bend diocese in Indiana, began in 1978 with a polite letter to a fellow bishop reporting parishioner complaints about the Rev. Thomas P. Forry’s temperament.
A year later, after Forry was accused of beating up his housekeeper, D’Arcy wrote to Cardinal Humberto S. Medeiros to complain that his earlier letter had been ignored, leaving parishioners with a priest beset by “severe emotional problems.”
In November 1983, D’Arcy’s concerns about another priest were even more pointed. In a letter to Bishop Thomas V. Daily, who was vicar general of the archdiocese, D’Arcy objected to a new parish assignment for the Rev. Richard A. Buntel, who had been accused of using drugs with young people and engaging in homosexual activity.
“I believe these allegations are true and if a man like this does not seek help, he should not be given an assignment,” D’Arcy said.
He added: “Young people are open to priests and when assaulted in this way, their souls are often irreparably damaged.”
In 1984, Law received the first of two cautionary letters from D’Arcy.
In the first, which became public earlier this year, D’Arcy expressed reservations about a parish assignment to Weston for the Rev. John J. Geoghan because of Geoghan’s “history of homosexual involvement [with] young boys.”
In the second, he objected to an assignment to the Office of Spiritual Development for the Rev. Robert V. Meffan, who had been accused of sexual misconduct with teenage girls.
D’Arcy, who declined to discuss his letter about Geoghan earlier this year, did not return a telephone call from the Globe yesterday.
The Rev. Robert W. Bullock, a leader of the Boston Priests Forum who knew D’Arcy as a student at St. John’s Seminary, said that D’Arcy’s warnings amount to a mixed message for Boston priests: positive because D’Arcy spoke up, but disturbing because he was the only one who did.
“Why weren’t there more?” Bullock said.
The Celtics rookie once had to knock on a neighbor’s door to ask for food. Now he’s on the threshold of NBA stardom.Continue reading »
The Swedish-born producer and DJ known as Avicii has been found dead in Muscat, Oman.Continue reading »
Only three years apart in age, the police officer and the career criminal accused of killing him could not have been more different.Continue reading »
The Red Sox have outscored their opponents, 34-6, in the first four games of their road tripContinue reading »
The North’s official Korean Central News Agency said the suspension of nuclear and ICBM tests went into effect Saturday.Continue reading »
Nearly 5,000 teaching and research assistants join the United Auto Workers, a union with blue-collar roots that has become a bastion of academic organizingContinue reading »
The Red Sox manager did not hesitate to keep J.D. Martinez out of the lineup for Friday night’s game in OaklandContinue reading »
Avicii kicked off his 2014 tour at Boston’s TD Garden with a crowded, sweaty concert that turned into what emergency officials call a “mass casualty incident.”Continue reading »
People magazine reports that Kick Kennedy, a model, had been dating banking heir Matthew Mellon for four months.Continue reading »