Next Score View the next score

    Pope’s laying of hands fuels debate on exorcism

    Vatican cautious in statement on actions at Mass

    Pope Francis laid his hands on the head of a young man after Sunday Mass in St. Peter’s Square. The man heaved deeply a half-dozen times then slumped in his wheelchair.
    Associated Press
    Pope Francis laid his hands on the head of a young man after Sunday Mass in St. Peter’s Square. The man heaved deeply a half-dozen times then slumped in his wheelchair.

    VATICAN CITY — Is Pope Francis an exorcist?

    The question has bubbled up ever since Francis laid his hands on the head of a young man in a wheelchair after celebrating Sunday Mass in St. Peter’s Square. The young man heaved deeply a half-dozen times, shook, then slumped in his wheelchair as Francis prayed over him.

    The television station of the Italian bishops’ conference reported Monday that it had surveyed exorcists, who agreed there was ‘‘no doubt’’ that Francis either performed an exorcism or a prayer to free the man from the devil.


    The Vatican was more cautious. In a statement Tuesday, it said Francis ‘‘didn’t intend to perform any exorcism. But as he often does for the sick or suffering, he simply intended to pray for someone who was suffering who was presented to him.’’

    Get Today's Headlines in your inbox:
    The day's top stories delivered every morning.
    Thank you for signing up! Sign up for more newsletters here

    Fueling the speculation is Francis’s obsession with Satan, a frequent subject of his homilies, and an apparent surge in demand for exorcisms among the faithful despite the irreverent treatment the rite often receives from Hollywood.

    In his very first homily as pope on March 14, Francis warned cardinals that ‘‘he who doesn’t pray to the Lord prays to the devil.’’

    He has since mentioned the devil on a handful of occasions, most recently in a May 4 homily when in his morning Mass in the Vatican hotel chapel he spoke of the need for dialogue — except with Satan.

    ‘‘With the prince of this world you can’t have dialogue: Let this be clear!’’ he warned.


    Specialists said Francis’s frequent invocation of the devil is a reflection both of his Jesuit spirituality and his Latin American roots, as well as a reflection of a Catholic Church weakened by secularization.

    ‘‘The devil’s influence and presence in the world seems to fluctuate in quantity inversely proportionate to the presence of Christian faith,’’ said the Rev. Robert Gahl, a moral theologian at Rome’s Pontifical Holy Cross University. ‘‘So, one would expect an upswing in his malicious activity in the wake of de-Christianization and secularization’’ in the world and a surge in things like drug use, pornography, and superstition.

    While belief in the devil is consistent with church teaching, the Holy See does urge prudence, particularly to ensure that the afflicted person isn’t merely psychologically ill.

    The Rev. Giulio Maspero, a Rome-based systematic theologian who has witnessed or participated in more than a dozen exorcisms, says he is fairly certain that Francis’s prayer on Sunday was either a full-fledged exorcism or a more simple prayer to ‘‘liberate’’ the young man from demonic possession.

    ‘‘When you witness something like that — for me it was shocking — I could feel the power of prayer,’’ he said in a phone interview, speaking of his own previous experiences.


    Sunday also happened to be the Pentacost, when the faithful believe Jesus’ apostles received the fullness of the Holy Spirit, and Maspero noted the symbolism.

    ‘‘The Holy Spirit is connected to the exorcism because . . . it is the manifestation of how God is present among us and in our world,’’ he said.

    The Vatican spokesman, the Rev. Federico Lombardi, sought to temper speculation that what occurred was a full-fledged exorcism. While he did not deny it outright — he said Francis had not ‘‘intended’’ to perform one — he stressed that the intention of the person praying is quite important.

    Late Tuesday, the director of TV2000, the television of the Italian bishops’ conference, went on the air to apologize for the earlier report.

    ‘‘I don’t want to attribute to him a gesture that he didn’t intend to perform,’’ said the director, Dino Boffo.

    That said, Francis’s actions and attitude toward the devil are not new: As archbishop of Buenos Aires, the former Cardinal Jorge Mario Bergoglio frequently spoke about the devil in our midst. In the book ‘‘Heaven and Earth,’’ Bergoglio devoted the second chapter to ‘‘The Devil’’ and said in no uncertain terms that he believes in the devil and that Satan’s fruits are ‘‘destruction, division, hatred and calumny.’’