fb-pixel

Pope Benedict wants his name removed from book about priestly celibacy

Pope Francis, right, greeted Pope Benedict XVI prior to the start of a meeting in St. Peter's Square at the Vatican
Pope Francis, right, greeted Pope Benedict XVI prior to the start of a meeting in St. Peter's Square at the VaticanAssociated Press/Gregorio Borgia, File/Associated Press

MORIA, Greece — In a day of accusations and finger-pointing inside the Vatican walls, Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI’s longtime aide is pushing to have the retired pontiff removed as co-author of a controversial book on priestly celibacy that many viewed as an attempt to influence Pope Francis.

Benedict’s aide, Archbishop Georg Gänswein, alleged that the retired pope had never intended to have his name on the book, saying there had been a ‘‘misunderstanding’’ with the other co-author, Cardinal Robert Sarah. But in a series of tweets and statements Tuesday, Sarah defended himself and said that Benedict, 92, had been fully kept in the loop and signed off on the plans.

Advertisement



Given the dispute, Sarah wrote, Benedict would be removed as co-author and instead listed as a contributor.

‘‘However,’’ Sarah said, ‘‘the complete text remains absolutely unchanged.’’

But even that didn’t fully solve the dispute. By evening, the book’s English publisher said it still considered Benedict a co-author.

The back-and-forth between Benedict’s main lieutenant and a conservative cardinal mirrored a larger debate inside the Catholic Church over what kind of role the retired pope should have, and whether he risks being manipulated as he grows more frail. Benedict had vowed after abdicating to remain silent on major church affairs, but in two high-profile instances over the past year, on the topics of sexual abuse and celibacy, he has shared opinions that either contradict Francis or put pressure on him.

‘‘The one good thing from this whole cheap operetta is that it’s now clearly demonstrated to show that the whole [pope] emeritus thing doesn’t work.’’ Ulrich Lehner, a theology professor at the University of Notre Dame.

The new book, whose excerpts were published Sunday by Le Figaro, amounts to an ardent defense of clerical celibacy at a time when Francis is considering an exception that would allow for some married priests in the Amazon region. According to those excerpts, Benedict wrote that celibacy was a sometimes painful but necessary ‘‘criterion’’ for ministry.

Advertisement



The question of over Benedict’s role in the book has consumed a slice of American Catholicism, with social media posts flying about who was likely telling the truth and why. In keeping with the polarization of the US church in recent years, conservatives were angered by the suggestion that Sarah — a traditionalist stalwart — had duped Benedict, or that Benedict wasn’t challenging Francis, while more liberal Catholics accused the emeritus pope of trying to undermine Francis.

John Allen, editor of the Catholic news site Crux and a biographer of Benedict, said Tuesday that, despite the fracas, Benedict and Sarah were on the same side of the celibacy debate.

‘‘They are both willing to entertain limited exceptions,’’ said Allen, noting that Benedict has facilitated married priests in the Western Church more than any other previous pope, allowing exceptions for married, Anglican priests who become Catholic.

‘‘I think this is less about pope versus pope than about rival camps in the church seeking to exploit both popes,’’ Allen said.

In a statement to Italy’s ANSA news service, Gänswein, Benedict’s personal secretary, said that the retired pope had never approved the project as co-author and had not ‘‘seen or authorized the cover,’’ which also included his photo. Gänswein called it ‘‘a misunderstanding that does not raise questions about Cardinal Sarah’s good faith.’’ Gänswein also asked that Benedict’s name be removed from introductory and concluding sections.

Advertisement



Sarah, the head of the Vatican’s liturgical office, took to Twitter to provide a different narrative of what happened, sharing several letters written by Benedict to Sarah in late 2019. In Sarah’s version, according to those letters and a separate statement, the cardinal had reached out to Benedict in September, asking the pope emeritus if he might be willing to share reflections on the priesthood, paying particular attention to the topic of celibacy.

Sarah says he also cautioned Benedict that such a subject might raise ‘‘debate’’ in the newspapers.

‘‘But I am convinced that the whole church needs such a gift,’’ Sarah says he told Benedict.

Benedict replied that he had already started writing along those lines, but hadn’t felt good about the work he was producing.

‘‘Then came your letter, with the unexpected request of a text directly on priesthood with particular attention to celibacy,’’ Benedict wrote. ‘‘So I reprised my work and will forward to you the text.’’

He passed along that text in October, according to Sarah, and later offered a final thank you to the cardinal in November.

‘‘As for me, the text can be published in the way you planned,’’ Benedict wrote.

Washington Post