Next Score View the next score

    the podium | James Stavridis

    Obama’s UN speech had the right set of recommendations

    President Obama addressed the General Assembly at the United Nations headquarters in New York on Wednesday.
    Justin Lane/EPA
    President Obama addressed the General Assembly at the United Nations headquarters in New York on Wednesday.

    Three key elements of President Obama’s speech before the UN stand out:

    1. The president took a tough stance on Ukraine, balanced by an offer to lift sanctions if Russia reverses course in their drive to destabilize Ukraine.

    This is the right mix of carrot and stick, and while it does not justify the annexation of Crimea, it at least condemns Russia in strong terms for acting on the wrong side of history.


    2. The president deployed a predictably unrelenting line against the Islamic State and called for full global condemnation in the form of a UN Security Council mandate. This opens the door to build out the coalition against the Islamic State from the 40 nations loosely aligned at the moment to something of truly global proportions. Notably he also called for Muslim states around the world to dramatically, loudly, and consistently condemn the Islamic State for draping themselves so inappropriately in the mantle of Islam.

    Get Today in Opinion in your inbox:
    Globe Opinion's must-reads, delivered to you every Sunday-Friday.
    Thank you for signing up! Sign up for more newsletters here

    3. Obama addressed a threat that could potentially be the worst of all: an unconfined spread of the Ebola virus, especially if it morphs into something even worse after repeated exposure to humans. This is the ultimate black swan (low probability, but huge impact), and the president rightly led a call to widen the response broadly.

    All in all, it was a wide-ranging speech with specific action points. Will it move the needle? The best hope is probably on Ebola. On the Islamic State, there may be some level of UN condemnation. And on Ukraine, Russian reversal seems highly unlikely. A mixed result, but the right set of recommendations in these three key areas.

    Watch Obama’s speech


    Obama lays out forceful blueprint to fight Islamic extremism

    Paul Farmer and Joia Mukherjee: Ebola’s front lines


    Andrew Bacevich: Seven key resources as US fight in Iraq resumes

    Jeff Jacoby: Why does ISIS behead its victims?

    James Carroll: New Cold War with Russia? Learn the right lessons

    Admiral James Stavridis is dean of The Fletcher School at Tufts University and former Supreme Allied Commander at NATO. He is also author of “The Accidental Admiral.’’