MIDDLESEX DISTRICT Attorney Marian Ryan could have honed the image of a tough prosecutor by objecting to the parole of Joseph Donovan, a 38-year-old Cambridge man who was convicted of first-degree murder before his 18th birthday. But she chose a wiser path by recommending that Donovan be subject to a “successful step-down transition” before returning to society.
Donovan, who has spent 22 years in prison, was convicted under the state’s joint venture law for the 1992 murder of Norwegian MIT student Yngve Raustein. He received a mandatory life sentence without parole. Donovan, who was barely 17 at the time, didn’t wield the murder weapon but he did instigate the attack. Efforts have been underway for years to commute his sentence. Raustein’s mother and the original trial judge are among those who have described Donovan’s sentence as excessive or unjust.
Donovan received a meaningful opportunity for parole due to a 2013 decision by the Supreme Judicial Court that retroactively eliminated mandatory life sentences without parole for anyone under 18. But chances still looked dim that he would convince the Parole Board he deserved freedom based, in part, on his disciplinary record during his earlier years of incarceration. District attorneys, who speak on behalf of the victims, have a lot of clout during parole hearings. And because Donovan’s case could be seen as a close call, DA Ryan’s objection might have destroyed his chance for freedom.
But Ryan took the high road. She didn’t object to parole. Instead, she reinforced the Parole Board’s requirement that Donovan spend six months in a rehabilitative program and one year in a lower-level security prison before his release. These are reasonable conditions. It was a sharp contrast to the position of her predecessor, former Middlesex DA Gerard Leone, who denounced the SJC decision that opened the way for reduced sentences for juvenile murderers.
Donovan is the third Massachusetts man since June to receive parole based on the SJC’s decision. There are about 60 additional prisoners in the same category. Some, like Donovan, deserve a second chance. Others pose too great a risk of reoffending. But each committed their crimes before reaching developmental and neurological maturity. And each deserves an eventual opportunity to prove they are ready to live outside the prison walls.
Some DAs may have trouble adjusting to the changes in the sentencing of juvenile murderers. Ryan, at least, has shown it is possible to make room for the redemption of a prisoner while protecting the safety of the public.
It’s hard to think of a more egregious example of putting party ahead of country than McConnell’s behavior.Continue reading »
Few seem as determined as Haley to emerge unscathed from the wreckage of the Trump presidency.Continue reading »
Luxury buildings drive up housing costs, suck up energy, and help rich people warehouse wealth. In exchange, they should pay a lot more than property taxes.Continue reading »
The costs of blocking financing for a new natural gas pipeline in New England — both financial and environmental — are already piling up.Continue reading »
For black people, this video has been viral forever.Continue reading »
Decades of painstaking work to balance ecological needs with local economies are being wiped away.Continue reading »
Relentless profanity is both a cause and an effect of the coarsening of American society.Continue reading »
When your skin is white, racism is something of a thought experiment — it’s not a daily experience of frustration, annoyance, humiliation, and fear.Continue reading »
The problem is that, while the arithmetic works, the politics often doesn’t.Continue reading »