Letters

letters | too soon to step down from supreme court?

Must political bias be so key to selecting justices?

Regarding the June 17 op-ed piece “Why Justice Ginsburg should retire”: Kent Greenfield’s argument rests on the premise that the most important criterion is to preserve a liberal vote on the Supreme Court. This presupposes, of course, that a justice’s qualification to serve is based primarily on political bias rather than legal acumen, relevant experience, or (dare we hope) wisdom.

A deliberately politicized Supreme Court will surely lose credibility. Shouldn’t the court be a place in which justice and fairness are assumed to prevail, without the taint of predisposed political viewpoints? And should we not aspire to select our justices accordingly?

Scott Simpson

Carlisle

Loading comments...
Real journalists. Real journalism. Subscribe to The Boston Globe today.